Share

The Brave, Living and Dead

by: Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Iraq War combat veteran Dave McBee. McBee, who served two tours of duty in Iraq, suffers from PTSD and lives in a homeless shelter. (Photo: Steven Senne / AP)

    In this bicentennial year of Abraham Lincoln's birth, I recently was rereading part of Doris Kearns Goodwin's epic history, "Team of Rivals." Once again it was stunning to see the number of casualties during the Civil War, the dead and wounded in four years of fighting exponentially outnumbering the American men and women killed and wounded in Iraq and Afghanistan over six and a half years of combat.

    On both sides of the Civil War, 618,000 were killed, although some estimate as many as 700,000. In just the three days of the Battle of Gettysburg, July 1863 - more than 51,000 dead and wounded. Chickamauga, Georgia, two days, September 1863, nearly 35,000. Chancellorsville, Virginia, four days, May 1863, more than 30,000. And on and on.

    "The war took young, healthy men and rapidly, often instantly, destroyed them with disease or injury," Drew Gilpin Faust notes in her 2008 book, "The Republic of Suffering: Death and the American Civil War." "... Loss became commonplace; death was no longer encountered individually; death's threat, its proximity and its actuality became the most widely shared of the war's experiences."

    Up until that time, Faust writes, the US Army had neither regular burial details nor grave-registration units. Such duties "seemed always to be an act of improvisation." Often the townspeople in or near a battleground wound up with the task. Many of the enlisted went unidentified, their bodies hastily placed in mass graves for fear of disease.

    Contrast that with the painstaking care given each of the dead today when they arrive from Iraq or Afghanistan at the Carson Center for Mortuary Affairs, the joint military facility headquartered at Dover Air Force Base in Delaware. Bodies and personal effects are thoroughly washed and cleansed, dress uniforms are individually tailored for the corpse, even the individual's wristwatch is carefully set to the time at the location where they fell. When each body is ready to leave Dover, all the service personnel at the mortuary stop what they're doing and form a line along the driveway, giving a slow, ceremonial salute as the hearse passes by.

    I learned this a few weeks ago, when I happened on the telecast of the HBO made-for-TV movie, "Taking Chance," the true story of Marine Lt. Col. Michael Strobl - played in the film by Kevin Bacon - who in 2004 escorted the body of Lance Corporal Chance Phelps, killed in Al Anbar Province, Iraq, to its final resting place in Dubois, Wyoming.

    I knew about the film but hadn't made plans to watch it. Nonetheless, coming upon it by accident, I was totally pulled in by the eloquent simplicity of the script, its attention to detail and lack of melodrama, the poignancy of Strobl's and Phelps's stories and the people "they" meet as Strobl accompanies the body on its final, cross-country journey. (You can continue to see the film through this month, at various times, well worth the fewer than 90 minutes it takes to view. Check the schedule at HBO.com.)

    Coincidentally, the film's release came at the same time as the Pentagon's announcement that it was lifting the ban on photographs and videos of bodies arriving at Dover, a proscription that had been in place since the first Gulf War in 1991. A similar renewed openness is taking place as the military and the Department of Veterans Affairs become more candid about suicide and PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder.

    Alarmed by the increasing rate of suicide, the Army has begun releasing monthly numbers, in addition to the annual reports produced in the past. 2008 was a record high - 128 confirmed suicides and 15 under investigation. The rate has been increasing steadily since 2004.

    Last month there were 18 suspected suicides, up from 11 the previous year. In January there were 24, up from five in January 2008. According to The Associated Press, "Usually the vast majority of suspected suicides are eventually confirmed, and if that holds true it would mean that self-inflicted deaths surpassed the 16 combat deaths [in January] reported in all branches of the armed forces in Iraq, Afghanistan and other nations considered part of the global war on terror."

    The Army's suicide rate is now exceeding the US civilian rate, for the first time since the military began keeping records in 1980.

    "Why do the numbers keep going up?" Army Secretary Peter Geren asked rhetorically at a press conference last month. "We cannot tell you."

    Experts say PTSD is a big reason - the RAND Center for Military Health Policy Research estimates that 19 percent of all the troops who have served in Iraq or Afghanistan suffer from it - some 300,000 men and women.

    Others point to the high rate of redeployment. According to a new report in the Boston Phoenix newspaper, "With the number of personnel that have served in the two theaters reaching nearly 1.8 million, critics estimate that one-third have served multiple deployments." With that redeployment come incredible stress and anxiety, not only on the battlefield but back home, where marriages and other relationships collapse from the strain.

    This past fall, the Army announced a $50 million, five-year joint study of suicide with the National Institute of Mental Health. And this week, the service will be wrapping up a month-long training program to help soldiers recognize suicidal behaviors in their comrades.

    But much more needs to be done. "We keep getting studies," Rep. John Murtha, chair of the House Defense Appropriations Committee, said at a March 3 hearing. "That's the problem with the Defense Department - they study it to death."

    What's more, according to an Army Medical Department's 2008 report, 33 percent of the troops in Afghanistan and 21.8 percent in Iraq say when it comes to mental health, their leaders discourage them from seeking help.

    That has to stop. We must treat the living as respectfully as we do the dead.

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.

Support Truthout's work with a $10/month tax-deductible donation today!
  

»


Michael Winship is senior writer at Public Affairs Television.
 

Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

And maybe the reason for all

And maybe the reason for all the suicides (and friendly fire deaths), is that the the mind of some are unable to deal with the truth of the horrors of what our country does in the name of 'democracy' once it has been uncovered for them.

Absolutely... and add to it

Absolutely... and add to it the 100 thousand Iraqi dead, the 2.5+ million plus refugees (80% of which are women and children), the devastated towns and villages, the destruction of all services, no water, no electricity, open sewers and very little medical services. A population and infrastructure purposely & systemically destroyed, the use of white phosphorous on civilians ( Falluja), etc etc. This was done all in the name of "democracy" and oil! Depressive? yes.

1980? So there are no

1980? So there are no comparative statistics from other wars sch as Viet Nam or Korea? I don't remember many Viet Nam 'comrades' doing this. I'm sure they're were, and still are, cases. But this 'war' is so contrived and useless, it has it's own set of quandaries for the soldiers to face. But I see a big problem with the way the soldiers are handled these days. They are lied to, and they know it. They are aggressed in ways that men in the previous battles would not accept. This war is hyped, so was Viet Nam. The difference is that the leadership has fallen to the ways of imperialism. In Viet Nam, we had an actual job to accomplish, now we are just being Americans. Our mission is too obviously oil. Most of us didn't know about the mineral rights we were actually fighting for in Viet Nam until later. It would be good to return to real education and throw off the hype. Many of these men know that the twin towers were not attacked by Iraqis. Many know it was no attack at all. Besides, it's a hard thing to suddenly realize that life and war are not video games. Or maybe our collective spirits are finally seeing war for what it really is, murder. We study history and glorify war and warriors. The reality is no glory at all. That's a hard pill for our young to swallow. Another difference is that this is no jungle full of hidden 'enemies'. It's up front in the neighborhoods where our soldiers can instantly see the effects of killing family members. What a nightmare, let's wake up from this America.

That's right! And consider

That's right! And consider this. This is the first war we did 'drug free'. In other wars we had heroin, opium and marijuana. That makes a big difference in the internal perceptions. Even the brass indulged. Life is quick and short everywhere in a war scenario. And now we still have brass foisting the war game videos onto our young. I feel the deepest remorse for the ones who do the push button war. I can't imagine what they're nightmares will be like as they grow older and wiser. Blood never washes off our hands, our hearts or our minds. It seeps into our dreams and sticks around through ever darker days. How many civilians have anguish and nightmares over this war? Depression and suicidal thoughts? A deeper sense of loss for they're young killed in the middle east? Deeper because we know this is wrong from day one. Wasteful! My deepest sympathies for the families on both shores. I know that they and they're progeny believe in what they are doing. I do respect that. All wars start in the heart. It's hard to play the pawn.

They can't tell you why the

They can't tell you why the suicides are going up, but I have a pretty good idea. Soldier's suffering in a meaningless stress filled hell, want it all just to stop.

How do the US civil war

How do the US civil war losses compare with those for Europe, Canada, Australis & the US during WWI? It's not too late to impeach Bush & Cheney, go after the rest of the Bushies: Powell, Rumsfield, Ashcroft, Yoo, Addington, Feith, Rice, Wolfowitz & Perle (and probably others) for war crimes or intentional infliction of global harm. I'm tired of reading about all the damage those have done, yet they take no responsibility & pay no price.

More Viet Nam vets died from

More Viet Nam vets died from suicide, drug overdose, and single-car accidents after they got home than died in combat. Anywhere, anytime, and for any reason, war is hell. Some few thrive on it. Most do the best they can. Just the few months' training to teach one to follow orders, act as part of a team, and kill, kill!, KILL!!!, changes one, irrevocably. It's part of the Dance. Fortunately, so is Give Peace a Chance.

Why should we treat our

Why should we treat our soldiers with respect, either alive or after they die? Because we are a pseudo-Christian nation or because it is the "right thing to do". Caring in this country is adding an American flag to the car antenna or applying a yellow ribbon sticker to the back of the gas guzzling SUV while you speed at 80mph down the highway to go to the mall or to the country club for a round of golf. All this talk is just a cover for our nation's hypocrisy that is as profound as that of the Germans during WWII who later pretended not to know that the Jews were being systematically exterminated.

Why is the focus confined to

Why is the focus confined to the plight of the warriors? What of the hundreds of thousands who have undergone wars as innocent bystanders? As the honorable George Carlin once pointed out, the sanitized PTSD used to be called shell shock, which at least carried the image of the ugliness that more closely captures the experience of horror of the thousands who'd returned from (mechanized) warfare, if not injured, utterly destroyed, nervous wrecks, traumatized. This natural revulsion of killing and death had to be overcome in order for wars of empire and pillage to be done by those who do not gain from it. To be a good warrior is to be a good beast. Exactly the wrong example for citizenship and a civil life. Yet, despite the military training, and attempts at the use of technology to dehumanize murder, man's hold on his morality can only be ignored for so long, and will not be denied. America must decide whether we are to be an Athens or a Sparta, for we cannot be both, and neither survived. The only difference is in how they lived, and in how we live: by killing or by helping, by fear or through cooperation. "Defense becomes offense, the protection of your children becomes the murder of another's, his threat becomes your preemption. You kill to stop the killing. Then you wonder, Are you the victim, or the slayer? But you are both." (James Carroll)

Send the upper middle class

Send the upper middle class girls and boys over there and see how quickly we would see the end of occupation. PS Folks, be careful of Orwellian talk: the word 'warrior' is propaganda vocabulary...it seeps in and before you know it, the citizenry is without thinking using the master's words.

We are such a nation of

We are such a nation of hypocrites. In the midst of all this, the military is pushing religion as a facifier. Ya, right - kill in the name of god and then return return to sitting in a pew on Sunday. It is insanity to continue to fight wars when we are too interdependent and too knowledgeable about the rest of the world.

All of this is something to

All of this is something to think about the next 4th of July when "patriotic" Americans will be waving the flag and firing up the grill. What farce!

If you go and do stuff your

If you go and do stuff your mother, father, preacher told you never to do, i.e., kill things that look a lot like people your conscience will start bothering you. You then have to decide you did these horrible things for a good reason and become a republican or you deal with the guilt then suicide becomes friendly. The nightmares don't help.

The grapevine is saying that

The grapevine is saying that the Vets being treated for PSTD are being given anti-depressants and the quite often go over the edge, These killer pills have also been implicated in the latest college shooting in Germany and also most of them in the States, I also hear that Vets taking these pills cannot own a Gun. I have no idea if that is correct or not

the only SURE FIRE way to

the only SURE FIRE way to stop these deaths? get out of these theaters of operation. why do you neglect the most obvious, logical, sensible optin?

I'll tell you why so many US

I'll tell you why so many US soldiers commit suicide: They've been brainwashed and taught to kill, so much that they eventually turn the gun on themselves and do just what they've been trained for: Pull the trigger, and take a life. That's what you get when you destroy the respect for life within the mind and heart of a young person equipped with guns and grenades, and throw them in a war that's meaningless for them, exept for the promise of vague words for abstract ideas such as "freedom" and "democracy". And the elite who organize the brainwashing know well what it is they are doing: War is meant to kill people, poor people, whatever the "side" they are on; Every poor soldier, every dangerous vet who kills themselves are just completing their mission: Seek and destroy, and save the rich from the rest.

Lets see, on the one hand

Lets see, on the one hand we have children who have to go and commit crimes against humanity. On the other hand we have so called "leaders" who make them go there. Gee, I wonder why the troops are having problems? Part of it is the fact that they realize that all the killing they have been a part of and witnessing so much daily death each day has been for nothing but the global games that these psychopath elites are running and all based on bold faced lies. You think they treat the Soldier's dead bodies the way they do out of respect? It's nothing but a phony parade to give the grieving parents at home the illusion of pride and country. We all know whats going on but we chose to allow it. This country used to be the home of the brave, now its the home of the slave. OF COURSE THEY ARE KILLING THEMSELVES, YOU WOULD TOO!

Let's see: politicians are

Let's see: politicians are honest, right?--and so are the upper ranks of the military. So when they tell young people that it's appropriate to go into some country on the other side of the world and start killing people they don't know, the young people should obey, right? People who surrender their will and judgment to others run a terrible risk: total emptiness at some point along the road. In a healthy society, everyone would be raised with this understanding, along with knowledge of how propaganda has stampeded hundreds of millions of ordinary people into slaughtering each other, before peace was declared and they realized once again that 'the enemy' were, after all, just regular folk in whom they could to a surprising extent recognize themselves.

Since 1950 , the U.S.A.

Since 1950 , the U.S.A. threatened , bombed and invaded directly or indirectly Korea, Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia, Grenada, Haiti [ 2 X ] , Panama, Nicaragua, Cuba, Lebanon, Philippeans, El Salvador, Chile, Guatamala, Yugoslavia, Somalia, Iraq [ 2 X ] , Iran1987 , Palestine, Zaire, Dominican Republic , Peru, Libya, Sudan, Afghanistan, South Africa [ we supported a Communist Terrorist Nelson Mandella ] , etc. After 8 years in Afghanistasn and 6 years in Iraq, we armed and trained their corrupt leaders , poured billions of dollars in to that sewer, isn't it time to let them take over and run their own country ? If they can't do it by now , they NEVER will. From now on when Washington wants to invade another country , we should DEMAND that 25 % of our Congressmen , Senators and all government employees will be sent to the FRONT LINES along side our troops for a 1 year tour of duty . They should be willing to prove their resolve and patriotism by fighting alongside our young men and women. It should be MANDATORY for all politicians up to 65 years of age . After they finish their tour of duty , the next 25 % will be sent to the front lines. Could it then be possible that we would have fewer wars in the future ?

Debating the whys and taking

Debating the whys and taking the high road isn't what's needed here. President Obama has called us to serve, and this is where our service is needed the most. I spent last year in a VA hospital with my son and thus came to befriend a lot of soldiers. They are loyal, they really feel that they are keeping us safe from violence and death. Their lives are destroyed doing this for us, would you do this for them? Service men and women need a friend, somebody to laugh with, or eat a meal with, someone to help them fight for VA benefits. We should be making a commitment to help their families stay together, find support groups, help them with housing - there are so many needs that this one cause will fill my volunteer agenda for the rest of my life. My experience at the VA hospitals has been the most rewarding, satisfying and loving offering of myself in my entire life. I love these men and women, I weep at their sorrows and hells. You must realize the hell they live with every day. Can you help those days to be happier and peaceful just with a little time and effort?

Maybe we feel so sorry for

Maybe we feel so sorry for them because in reality, we killed our children, our 'warriors'. Who goes into the ghettos and feels sorry for the kids the police shot? Do these officers commit suicide? Yes, in spirit, they do.

It's sad to say but more

It's sad to say but more often than not, I'm ashamed of the actions of our great country and the people who run it. Mercy on us all?

The US military treats its

The US military treats its enlisted people like cannon fodder. It has routinely exposed them to chemicals (Viet Nam and Gulf War 1) and depleted-uranium munitions. Even during World War 2, the Army expected infantry to assault a well-defended beach(Omaha) carrying a full pack; some men died in the shallow water because the weight was too much. The "can-do" attitude... The suicides are also no surprise; many of these people are repelled by what the military asks them to do and can't stomach any more. It might be interesting to compare how other NATO armies treat their people. It should be clear to everyone that the US military is the strong-arm squad for its empire, not the "defenders of our nation" (which is their intended purpose).

Let's rename it "The Battle

Let's rename it "The Battle of the Bush"!

A Viet Nam veteran

A Viet Nam veteran killed himself here in my town today. This morning. GSW thru the head. I got my hearing impaired by gunfire before the Viet Nam War began and they wouldn't take me back when I tried to return to duty. I don't know what to do to help these guys, I just don't. I guess I'll just keep going and feel the grief like all the other vets and his family. Nothing good comes of war, It is the most collossal waste of money and material and lives. Ruination an a Grand Scale.