Share

Honeybees in Danger

by: Evaggelos Vallianatos, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Industrial, pesticide-dependent agricultural practices in the United States are creating a death trap for the honeybee and threatening the human-bee symbiotic relationship forged over millenia. (Photo: Getty Images)

    When I was teaching at Humboldt State University in northern California 20 years ago, I invited a beekeeper to talk to my students. He said that each time he took his bees to southern California to pollinate other farmers' crops, he would lose a third of his bees to sprays. In 2009, the loss ranges all the way to 60 percent.

    Honeybees have been in terrible straits.

    A little history explains this tragedy.

    For millennia, honeybees lived in symbiotic relationship with societies all over the world.

    The Greeks loved them. In the eighth century BCE, the epic poet Hesiod considered them gifts of the gods to just farmers. And in the fourth century of our era, the Greek mathematician Pappos admired their hexagonal cells, crediting them with "geometrical forethought."

    However, industrialized agriculture is not friendly to honeybees.

    In 1974, the US Environmental Protection Agency licensed the nerve gas parathion trapped into nylon bubbles the size of pollen particles.

    What makes this microencapsulated formulation more dangerous to bees than the technical material is the very technology of the "time release" microcapsule.

    This acutely toxic insecticide, born of chemical warfare, would be on the surface of the flower for several days. The foraging bee, if alive after its visit to the beautiful white flowers of almonds, for example, laden with invisible spheres of asphyxiating gas, would be bringing back to its home pollen and nectar mixed with parathion.

    It is possible that the nectar, which the bee makes into honey, and the pollen, might end up in some food store to be bought and eaten by human beings.

    Beekeepers are well aware of what is happening to their bees, including the potential that their honey may not be fit for humans.

    Moreover, many beekeepers do not throw away the honey, pollen and wax of colonies destroyed by encapsulated parathion or other poisons. They melt the wax for new combs: And they sell both honey and pollen to the public.

    Government "regulators" know about this danger.

    An academic expert, Carl Johansen, professor of entomology at Washington State University in Pullman, Washington, called the microencapsulated methyl parathion "the most destructive bee poisoning insecticide ever developed."

    In 1976, the US Department of Agriculture published a report by one of its former employees, S. E. McGregor, a honeybee expert who documented that about a third of what we eat benefits from honeybee pollination. This includes vegetables, oilseeds and domesticated animals eating bee-pollinated hay.

    In 2007, the value of food dependent on honeybees was $15 billion in the United States.

    McGregor also pointed out that insect-pollinated legumes collect nitrogen from the air, storing it in their roots and enriching the soil. In addition, insect pollination makes the crops more wholesome and abundant. He advised the farmer he should never forget that "no cultural practice will cause fruit or seed to set if its pollination is neglected."

    In addition, McGregor blamed the chemical industry for seducing the farmers to its potent toxins. He said:

    "[P]esticides are like dope drugs. The more they are used the more powerful the next one must be to give satisfaction" and therein develops the spiraling effect, the pesticide treadmill. The chemical salesman, in pressuring the grower to use his product, practically assumes the role of the "dope pusher." Once the victim, the grower, is "hooked," he becomes a steady and an ever-increasing user.

    No government agency listened to McGregor.

    The result of America's pesticide treadmill is that now, in 2009, honeybees and other pollinators are moving towards extinction.

    In October 2006, the US National Research Council warned of the" "demonstrably downward" trends in the populations of pollinators. For the first time since 1922, American farmers are renting imported bees for their crops. They are even buying bees from Australia.

    Honeybees, the National Academies report said, pollinate more than 90 crops in America, but have declined by 30 percent in the last 20 years alone. The scientists who wrote the report expressed alarm at the precipitous decline of the pollinators.

    Unfortunately, this made no difference to EPA, which failed to ban the microencapsulated parathion that is so deadly to honeybees.

    Bee experts know that insecticides cause brain damage to the bees, disorienting them, making it often impossible for them to find their way home.

    This is a consequence of decades of agribusiness warfare against nature and, in time, honeybees. In addition, beekeepers truck billions of bees all over the country for pollination, depriving them of good food, stressing them enormously, and, very possibly, injuring their health.

    -------

    Evaggelos Vallianatos, former EPA analyst, is the author of "This Land Is Their Land" and "The Passion of the Greeks.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.

Support Truthout's work with a $10/month tax-deductible donation today!
  

»


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

We don't have to worry about

We don't have to worry about the extermination of mankind because of terroists. The human race will exterminate itself because of greed and stupidity long before that. The rise in the cancer rate should be warning enough.

We can do a lousy job of

We can do a lousy job of raising our children, but we are really good at ruining a beautiful planet.

Monsanto bears a good deal

Monsanto bears a good deal of the responsibility... genetically modifying crops to be pesticide resistant and a slew of other changes. The bees aren't the only thing affected! The World According To Monsanto is a must-watch.

The media bears a huge

The media bears a huge responsibility as well. When they report the story of the decline of honeybees it's always presented as a 'mystery'. The economic power of the huge chemical companies is such that they can suppress the connection between their products and this 'mystery'. Bees aren't the only ones in peril, of course, as radline9 said, cancer in humans is not only caused by the poisons chemicals these companies produce, they then charge exorbitant amounts for the poisons they choose to call "chemotherapy agents" which are nothing more than cell killers. It has been known since I had breast cancer in 1993-4 that organochlorine chemicals are a causative agent, but you'll still see media stories about the role of 'lifestyle'--food, alcohol, smoking--in breast cancer. Yes, it's about food, but indirectly: food bathed in pesticides is carcinogenic. The chemical companies have also spread their disinformation about the 'cancer clusters', that they are due to statistical anomaly or 'better screening.' BULL--the Long Island cancer cluster is due to the area having been built on pesticided potato fields, the one in Marin to dioxon dumps, in Silicon Valley to buildup on former orchard and farmland. The bees are the canaries in the coal mine. Or maybe we should change the phrase to 'the bees failing to return to the hive.'

No one commenting on the

No one commenting on the beekeepers who sell the contaminated honey and wax? Does Monsanto, or lax regulation, "make" them do that? Are farmers forced to use more and more pesticides, prevented from farming organically? No...these are matters of choice, not regulation or lack of regulation. Individuals are making bad choices.

does anybody know the effect

does anybody know the effect of Bt on honey bees? please write a comment if you have something to share. thanks!

No bees in Dallas, at least

No bees in Dallas, at least in my part of Dallas, going on three years now. Used to be, us bee-a-phobics would be dodging em everywhere we went. Now - nada. Every time I point it out, I'm called paranoid and nutty... until a few days later, when I get the "hey, you're right - no bees!" phone call...

It's probably 30 years too

It's probably 30 years too late to do anything to save ourselves, but yes, we can put the blame on the agribusiness giants, especially Monsanto (which appears to be run by greedy, totalitarian maniacs), our bought and paid for Congress, and the apathy and ignorance and plain stupidity of the average American who doesn't seem to realize that our days on this once beautiful planet are numbered. But I have reached an age where if the human race is exterminating itself because of the above, I just plain don't care any more. Obviously we have squandered our birthright. Maybe we don't deserve to continue as a species.

Byard Pidgeon, I'm not sure

Byard Pidgeon, I'm not sure why the drug pusher metaphor is so difficult for you to understand. It's an inescapable reality that pesticide and fertilizer use depletes soils of their nutrients. When soils lose their nutrients, farmers have to use more and more pesticides and chemicals just to maintain production. Sure, they can switch to organic, but that necessarily requires lower yields as farmers allow soils to regain their vitality. And lower yields means lower incomes, which farmers who depend on their crops for their livelihood often cannot afford. It's a vicious circle that's very difficult to break. Yes, individuals are capable of making their own decisions, but they don't control every aspect of their lives. Complete individual agency only exists in Ayn Rand novels and other fantasies. The problem is corrupt institutions like the federal agencies and multinational corporations, not just bad decisions made by individuals.

Yes, but when are you folk

Yes, but when are you folk going to take the time to figure out what causes all these dangers to human life so you can put a stop to it? You're not going to be able to act to improve the situation as long as you are blaming greed&stupidity because, apart from the fact that they are not valid causes, those things are not curable!

Response to Byard: It is

Response to Byard: It is usually beyond the resources of small-scale beekeepers to determine whether their products have any contaminants. We can try to lay all responsibility for pesticide use at the door of individual farmers, but that ignores the systemic pressures to raise production and compete with corporate producers. As with many problem with ecological consequences, individual self-regulation has always been advocated but has consistently proven not to work. The state must be involved.

Monsanto has resorted to

Monsanto has resorted to using hit-men and depraved, backwards methods more suited to Medieval Dark Ages people. There is proof on paper enough to indict them like any other Federal Criminal. They better stop thinking they are some kind of "mafia." European and American Military Intelligence is all over their misdeeds like flies on shit.

yes, they, the bees, have

yes, they, the bees, have hard, short, highly regulated lives under normal conditions. Adding the burden of a constant assault from Chevron, Monsanto, Dow, and the like is just too much. No wonder strains of really pissed off bees have evolved (e.g. "killer bees").

Good thing "Change you can

Good thing "Change you can believe in" Obama is sticking up for the environment and the humble, hard-working honey bee, er. oh yeah, he's not.

I will be commenting on "

I will be commenting on " the beekeepers who sell the contaminated honey and wax". Monsanto, or lax regulation, "make" them do that? Of course. Farmers are forced to use more and more pesticides, and are largely prevented from farming organically because of the cost competition from the other farmers using Monsanto's stuff. Placing Monsanto and the farmers on the same level is ignorant to say the least. If an outfit is bigger, it should set the example for others to follow and not the opposite. At least this is how it worked before the empire started its decline.

thank you so much for this

thank you so much for this piece. i am a late-comer to Humboldt County, where i have been gardening organically for the past 8 years. Each spring for the last three years or so i have waited anxiously to see whether or not the honeybees have made it through another cycle, while my garden burgeons with its increasing load of blossoms. and the honeybees come, in correspondingly greater numbers as my garden has more nectar to offer them. this is hardly only my doing: many of my neighbors are also committed to forgo chemically treating their lawns and flower and vegetable beds, and most of the market farmers in northern Humboldt seem to be, as well. your article reminds me just how important such community commitments are.

Up here in this part of

Up here in this part of Canada no sprays are allowed,you can't even buy them now. our bees are still around. Your poisoning yourselves down there. your water to your food is all poisonous. I suppose if your health system is for profit there is going to be lots of sickness mandated by the govt.

"It is no measure of health

"It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society."

Your article describing the

Your article describing the deliberate slaughter of the honeybee contains this phrase: "This is a consequence of decades of agribusiness warfare against nature..." While I most emphatically agree with the thrust of your article, I emphatically take exception to your above conclusion. The warfare is NOT against nature, the warfare is AGAINST humanity. The devil worshipers directing this warfare have an old agenda that is part of the (not so new) New World Order agenda to depopulate this planet . See "Optimum Population Trust" for a "vision" of where they wish to take the world's population. Depopulation is not the primary objective. And the killing of the honeybees may be described as "collateral damage." I hope you ask me, "You mention the New World Order, that implies an Old World Order. It also raises a number of other questions. Who is behind the NWO? When did it begin? Who is behind the OWO? And when did it begin?" You might also challenge my credibility by asking, "You call "them" devil worshipers? Where is your evidence? What documentation can you present to prove your charge?"

The good news is that even

The good news is that even if we kill everything and everybody, some sort of ecosystem will arise again in only a few million years. If a symbol-wielding species like ours eventually appears, the remaining signs of our brief reign as the dominant species will tell them quite a cautionary tale. Maybe they'll figure out how to avoid collapsing the ecosystem that sustains them. (Unlike humans, who have not yet adapted to the cautionary tale told by Easter Island, for example.)

Microencapsulated products

Microencapsulated products are not generally used on crops as they can burn the plants acting like little lens. I do think that pesticides are a big problem for bee's. Non repellent products can be transferred to colonies. Normally a bee could not get back into the colony if it had insecticide on it, or would die in the field, But new insecticides are not detectable by the guard bee's and have a delayed reaction. Another problem with bee's is mites. They are very small and would succumb to insecticides before the bees. If they live, there is not very much insecticide in the hive, certainly not enough to kill bees. The author of this piece is decades out of date, and knows not of what he writes.

So "colony collapse" is

So "colony collapse" is man-made. The attack against bees started with the use of Sevin. Don't use Sevin. It also kills bees.

This actually does seem like

This actually does seem like a partial answer (at the very least) to the "mysterious" so-called colony collapse disorder which has decimated honeybees throughout much of the world for some years. A time-released insecticide brought back to the hive by worker bees would result in just what is being described. Countless homeowners use the same principle when they put bait out for ants--in this case, the problem lies in an insecticide which cannot distinguish between insects. I must question the author's contention that "poisoned honey and beeswax" being sold to American consumers. While I cannot recall the half-life of methyl parathion offhand, I do know that honey sits in an open comb cell for at least 21 days before it is ready to be "capped" by the bees and thus becoming honey. Any time-released insecticide would be long gone by then, all the more so since the nectar in an uncapped comb is constantly evaporating, aided by the activity of the bees, until it becomes sufficiently concentrated to be capped. Processed honey (the stuff from the grocery store) is both pasteurized and filtered to remove things like botulinus spores which are also routinely brought into the hive by bees (hence warnings about feeding raw honey to infants). As a former beekeeper, I much prefer the raw stuff, but there is absolutely no reason for concern over the product which has been processed for store shelves. Given the aging process I have described, I would have no concern about eating raw honey either.

you all would like proof

you all would like proof read reverlations one world government nwo ring a bell to do this first money banks then food every body is just doing thier job OK! you can't stop this this is not a mistake it's the agenda greed is being use to do this.I'm all right jack will sink us all how much money is monsanto making from gm crap few quid and it will be here like a charge.It can be changed once it's in you don't what is or what it will change in to. why so meny rules to live by so you don't think for self. steal all your time untill it's to late you are being lied to at every leval wake up blind leading the blind government line thire pokectts and carry out the agenda this is going on world wide banking they have just got a morgage 3trillion you have to pay back OK! usa +GB +the rest you will not be able pay it of it's so big lets say you work for us now OK ! brown blair are part of it obarma change oh sure the agenda theft of your feedom and money so you can't fight back devide and conker

Make no mistake, I am not a

Make no mistake, I am not a religious person at all, quite the contrary; but even I can sense that the end-time for humanity is just around the corner with revelations like this with the bees, the destruction of our once beautiful planet and all its lifeforms, almost a daily thing now on the net. This Garden of Eden shall soon be no more.

I wish we had all fought

I wish we had all fought these monsters. I wish we were brave enough to go to the rich enclaves where they live and demand an accounting, and force them to stop.

Does it make sense to start

Does it make sense to start a petition bringing awareness to the suspect products and asking to legally ban them ? How about having local state and municipal laws ban the sale of nerve gaz pesticides immediately ?

Ron, (21:33) while you don't

Ron, (21:33) while you don't spell very well, you got it down politically.

some proof of contaminated

some proof of contaminated honey would be nice! footnotes?

spell checked Thank you for

spell checked Thank you for this article and for your other writings. The real dilemma here is that half the world cares and gets it. The other half consists of people who are clueless and people that are so greedy they could care less if they bring the world to brink of human extinction, as long as they have power and money in their pocket. There are only two possible solutions at this late date. The first, which I prefer, is a push for a renaissance in human society. Rediscovering the value of life, our relationship with nature and how if we nurture it we will be nurtured. Discovering that it is music, art, and dance that nurture the soul, not bombs. Our food should be respected as the source of our life not a source of profit. If we alleviate the suffering of one, we are all elevated. Corporations must be punished for actions that hurt others or the planets resources. The judges of this should be . . .well there's the rub. If you are a politician, an academic, or a worker on the take, on the dope of money you CANNOT BE INVOLVED IN THE DECISION MAKING PROCESS AT ALL. So option two- the complete collapse of the industrial world. The end of the world economy as it exists, the collapse of big government an apocalyptic crash that removes the Monsanto's, the GE's from the equation of forces us to start from scratch. From the comments above, I think we are headed for option 2.

Does this look like part of

Does this look like part of a plan?

Read an article last night

Read an article last night on how Monsanto is even buying up a huge number of independent seed companies in the US. Frightening...

"It is possible that the

"It is possible that the nectar, which the bee makes into honey, and the pollen, might end up in some food store to be bought and eaten by human beings." As it stands alone, this statement does not indicate the inclusion of the microcapsules... but in the context of the article it suggests that the nectar would be contaminated, causing the honey to become contaminated. I am not disputing the validity of this statement or the research behind it, but I am wondering if any (independent/3rd party) laboratory research has been done that may support this statement? If there are findings, would it have the same effect on humans as bees?

An investigation of

An investigation of CHEMTRAILS needs to be brought into the discussion as well.