Share

Obama's Health Care Struggle: Waterloo or Water Down?

by: Bill Moyers and Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
(Artwork: Elon Sharton-Bierig / Medill Reports)

    Push finally came to shove in Washington this week as the battle for health care escalated from scattered sniper fire into all-out combat. If it all seems to be getting more and more confusing, join the club. It's hard to see what's happening through all the gun smoke.

    The Republicans have more than health care reform in their bombsights - they want a loss for Obama so crushing it will bring the administration to its knees and restore GOP control of Congress after next year's elections. In the words of Republican Senator Jim DeMint, "If we're able to stop Obama on this, it will be his Waterloo. It will break him."

    The "Waterloo" of DeMint's metaphor, of course, is not the 1974 Abba hit but the battle in 1815 that ended Napoleon Bonaparte's rule as Emperor of France - a humiliating defeat and a turning point in European history. Right-wingers like Glenn Beck see Obama as Napoleon incarnate, a popular emperor who must be stopped.

    Here's what Beck said on his television show Monday, July 20: "I'm telling you, this guy is dangerous. He's never lost before. He won't understand ... like, 'Who are you to question me?' I mean, this guy is practically an imperial President now. When he starts to lose and people start to question him and push him back against the wall, he's not gonna know how to react."

    The Republican strategy is almost identical to the way they turned health care into Waterloo for Bill and Hillary Clinton in 1993. Back then, one of their chief propagandists, William Kristol, urged his party to block any health care plan for fear that Democrats would be seen as "the generous protector of middle class interests." Now he's telling the GOP to "go for the kill ... throw the kitchen sink ... drive a stake through its heart ... We need to start over."

    So in lockstep are the Republicans that when strategist Alex Castellanos issued a memo outlining their battle plan, party chairman Michael Steele parroted large sections of it word for word in a speech at Washington's National Press Club. Asked a health care-related question that took him off script, Steele replied, "I don't do policy."

    As the Republicans fired away, big business stepped up the attack too, their lobbying and advertising guns blazing. The Chamber of Commerce, for one, announced a major campaign of rallies and print and Internet ads to crush the White House plan for a competitive public option allowing consumers to choose between a government plan and private health insurance. In key states where members of Congress remain on the fence, the airwaves are vibrating with television commercials aimed at shifting hearts and minds away from any change that might threaten profits.

    President Obama rejected the Republicans' Waterloo metaphor and mounted a massive media counteroffensive of his own. But the President has already run into booby traps of his own making and minefields laid by members of his own party, exacerbated when the Congressional Budget Office reported that reform plans, instead of controlling costs, would send the national debt further into the stratosphere.

    Meanwhile, supporters who want to scrap the present system for fundamental change are staring glumly though the fog of war at a battlefield in total disarray. They fear that in the White House's desire to get a bill - any bill - passed by Congress, it will have been so compromised, so bent to favor the big interests, that it will be less Waterloo than watered down, a steady diluting of the change they had hoped for and that America needs.

    The big drug companies are already so pleased with what they've been promised that they've brought back Harry and Louise - the make-believe couple who starred in TV ads that helped torpedo the Clinton health care plan - but this time they're in favor of reform.

    According to The Associated Press, the drug industry's trade group PhRMA (the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America) and the drug company Pfizer "reported spending more money than other health care organizations on lobbying in the second quarter of this year" - $6.2 million from PhRMA, $5.6 million from Pfizer.

    "Including its latest report, PhRMA has now spent $13.1 million lobbying so far this year. Pfizer has reported $11.7 million in lobbying expenses for 2009."

    This is part of the reason, as Alicia Mundy and Laura Meckler recently wrote in The Wall Street Journal, that "the pharmaceuticals industry, which President Barack Obama promised to 'take on' during his campaign, is winning most of what it wants in the health-care overhaul."

    Their story describes "a string of victories" plucked from the Senate Finance Committee by drug company lobbyists, including no cost-cutting steps, no cheaper drugs to be allowed across the border from Canada, and no direct Federal government negotiations with the pharmaceutical companies to lower Medicare drug prices.

    And that's not all. The Senate Health Committee is giving the biotech industry monopoly protection against competition from generic drugs for 12 years after they go on the market.

    No wonder the cost of reform keeps going up and up and up. Could it be that Harry and Louise are happier because, this time, they're in on the deal?

    --------

    Bill Moyers is managing editor and Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program Bill Moyers Journal, which airs Friday night on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers. Research provided by editorial producer Rebecca Wharton.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.

Support Truthout's work with a $10/month tax-deductible donation today!
  

»


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

I believe that the health

I believe that the health care industry lobby has skewed current debate with the idea that the main objective is to reign in costs. β€œLowering costs” has become the central talking point in all the mainstream news reportage, including NPR. The main problem is not high costs, however. We need to create a system that takes care of the currently uninsured and under-insured. The best way to lower costs would be to institute a single-payer system and get rid of resource-wasting profiteering. Meanwhile, the industry seems to have Washington diverted with a notion of incremental change, using β€œcosts” as a scare tactic. Consider the uninsured and under-insured, not just the upper middle class.

It makes sense that the

It makes sense that the first decade of a new century should shake up all established values - look at what happened last century. This time we already have wars all over the place, so it's not a question of starting a war but merely of escalating existing ones. Meanwhile Americans are hanging on to a moribund system that's become a millstone around their necks. History shows (Rome, Germany) that they won't be able to throw it off but that it will drag them down - with everybody talking a mile a minute. Pete Edler, Stockholm

If it comes to SinglePayer

If it comes to SinglePayer or Rebublicans, I'll take single payer. Don't stand in the way.

Forget the RepubliCONS and

Forget the RepubliCONS and the DemocRATS! Both parties are bought and paid for by special interests and there is nowhere near enough support for not-for-profit, single payer health care in the Congress. If a bill is passed, it will be a sorry tatter of compromises that will only exacerbate the present sad joke that passes for a real health care system in this country. Without true representation of the people in the legislature, things are only going to get more expensive and less effective. The only hope for us is to actually elect a majority of representatives that are not simply special interest shills. Vote Third Party and vote out 90% of the incumbent crooks that inhabit the halls of Congress. Get on line and get ready for 2010!

If the Dem pols didn't

If the Dem pols didn't belong to the same owners as the Reps, Obama would have a chance of getting something done; but with a house full of bought obstructionists, what chance does he (and we) have?

The GOPers tell us that the

The GOPers tell us that the plans so far are "dangerous." The liberals tell us they are watered down. Maybe they are just right, then. We have to start somewhere and we aren't going to get all we want the first time the horse gets out of the barn. Like everything else in life, this plan will "evolve" through the years. But if we get NO plan on the table, we will be living with the status quo for years to come. Americans and our economy can't take that. Folks. Whatever you did to get President Obama elected, do as much for this health care reform. Phone calls, contributions, e-mails, blogging, whatever it was, get busy.

Well, I guess this is one

Well, I guess this is one more (or more than one) reason NOT to support ObamaCare: "Their story describes "a string of victories" plucked from the Senate Finance Committee by drug company lobbyists, including no cost-cutting steps, no cheaper drugs to be allowed across the border from Canada, and no direct Federal government negotiations with the pharmaceutical companies to lower Medicare drug prices." Perhaps I am in a bad mood, because my sibling just informed me last week that one of his new prescriptions will cost $900 a month. Yes, he is a Vietnam vet, and no...he's not getting any breaks because of his service. Unlike Obama and most of his administration...he actually fought for this country.

In the last administartion

In the last administartion that invaded countries, only Powell served in military. Usually this is true. Since LBJ or Carter, so who cares. You really want generals running the country? That has nothing to do with anything. This country was set up to prevent the military from declaring war on their own. Lobbyists, money is the problem, and the courts, mostly stuffed in the past 20 years with preconceived notions of conservative judicial activism, say money is speech and protected in politics. So, go figure. If Republicans do regain control, having even less ideas than the Democrats, they will fail big time, but as their propensity is to foment hatred to stay popular, it will be hell (for all the world, you gloating Europeans)

start the discussion over.

start the discussion over. start with single-payer and don't give up anything - end with single-payer.

We have all been told that

We have all been told that we can keep our existing policies. What they are not telling us is, as defined on page 16 of the House Bill, we can only change to the government plan when and if we leave our current plan. we cannot change private insurers. Of course, Congress will not fall under these restrictions. Also note that there is no restraint of trial lawyers; something that really would cut medical costs.

The republicans are working

The republicans are working to bring Obama and his administration down. Did the democrats do that to Bush? No, and it's what got Obama and the democrats elected. I see the tide turning toward some form of health care reform. Like Lynne says, it's time to work for this. While it's not likely we will get huge reform, it is likely we will get some reform and relief. We might get a standing platform for health care that will continue to be improved. Don't give up hope now! Do something!

In the face of runaway costs

In the face of runaway costs under Massachusetts mandatory health insurance program reported in Thursday's USA Today, the Congress and the President cannot ignore genuine concerns about cost containment especially in the current economic environment. Taxing the rich is a great solution (if you're not rich) but these taxes only cover somewhere in the neighborhood of one third to one half of projected costs. Claiming that anyone raising concerns about this legislation is merely a special interest is off the mark.

Obama and the Dems realize

Obama and the Dems realize it yet, but they're toast in the next election. They conned us with the "we need 60 votes", and now bend over backward to avoid using their power. I don't think I'm the only one who will be voting 3rd party in the next election.

You have to stay with

You have to stay with Obama... it may take a while... but he's the way through... and it doesn't matter what aspect of governance you are talking about. He has to find his way through and around everybodys fears... and that's not easy. Stay with him! Australia.

Republicans: Comforting the

Republicans: Comforting the Comfortable for Nearly a Century. Frankly, at this point, I don't care if the national debt increases ten-fold. That's not real money to me. The real money is my slim paycheck and the skyrocketing cost of health insurance. National debt? That seems pretty abstract at this point. Besides, why is the health insurance industry so afraid of competing with the government? Afraid of competition? Hmmm.

To Edgeofnowhere:

To Edgeofnowhere: Definitely vote out the CONS and the RATS. Go Local with petitions to remove from office those guilty of malfeasance while serving in the US Congress. Make certain that there are paper trail voting systems in every County of every State. Check and re-check your own Elections Auditors to make sure they are doing honest and efficient jobs. Take care how and where you spend your money, if you have any. Talk politics with your kids so they will know you care about their futures.

It gets a whole lot less

It gets a whole lot less confusing when you/we are honest. It is NOT about health care. It is about health INSURANCE Not at all the same thing. It's easy to figure out that when you insert for profit into health care, it does not work. It has never worked, even though the country spends twice as much per person as all the many countries that have single payer health care. So when you sweep single payer off the table, as Obama has done, there is no hope. It can only get worse. So why do we even care about the debate? We should take for granted that whatever the politicians cobble together about health insurance, it will be worse than it is now. Obama was supposed to change Washington, remember? In six months Washington has already won.

Even with majority in the

Even with majority in the House and the Senate, the Democrats are unable to fulfill the promises of the last election. Obama has good intentions and is committed but his party is as obstructionist as the Republicans. The Democratic Party is fragmented and lack coherence. Its members do not share the same principles. β€œBlue Dogs” type politicians are chameleons, that act either as republicans or democrats, whatever is more convenient. It is against their interests to provide universal health care coverage. The mainstream media confuse people. They spread false information which people believe. With an uncooperative party, the media, conservatives, industry, and Republicans sabotaging, Obama is facing an insurmountable task. He needs all the support he can get. Those who oppose Obama will not rest; they have decided to make him fail. Obama is fighting for policies that many of us share. Anybody in favor on those policies should not abandon him. The sharks are out there ready to devour our hopes for a better country.

It is positively astounding

It is positively astounding that the MSM and the liberals are all trying to turn this into a Republican plan to DESTROOOY OBAAAAMAAAA! MUAHHAHA! DEMOCRATS ARE HAVING A PROBLEM WITH HIM TOO Everytime he doesn't get his way he takes up the airwaves like a mini-Chavez. It's getting pretty pathetic to watch him get on the TV and start yelling "I'M THE PRESIDENT"! He has held more press conferences in the last 7 months than W did during his entire 8 years! Not that I could stomach W either but seriously, this guy is losing his marbles.

Thank You 00:40 β€”

Thank You 00:40 β€” Anonymous. Until Americans start READING their news again, and asking questions for the first time, don't expect the level of public discourse to get any better. We even have people posting here who sound like Glen Beck is their main source of opinion in lieu of journalism. As long as the Murdoch funded propagandists have a louder bull horn to shout their self-interests from the rooftops, the rest of us (the overwhelming majority of us) will not have our opinions reflected by public figures. Too many people in this country are incapable of critical thinking and are easily manipulated by simple-minded hypocritical hysterical newspeak to actually ask themselves, in logical terms, what the financial motivations might be behind the opinions spouted at them on television. A great companion article to this one is "The Great Tax Con Job" by Thom Hartmann: http://www.truthout.org/072509Z?n . Most Truthout readers have probably already checked it out, but I think it's message is so important that it bears repeating here. It illustrates the very motives that are at play in the current "healthcare" "debate".

So the Republicans don't

So the Republicans don't care about healthcare reform or the American people, they just want to "bring Obama down", "make sure he fails". Ah, typical politics. Ain't it great to be an American and feel so loved by our elected officials who are suppose to be working for us, not some lobbyist or croney.

I'm an American who has

I'm an American who has lived overseas for the past 15 years and one who has experienced a complete change of my view of life without the impending fear that is shared by so many Americans of "what if I get sick, then what happens?" The fact that becoming "like France" in terms of healthcare is used as a BAD thing to frighten Americans from having any is astounding. It shows how our heads are literally in the sand. The American public has become worse than a pawn to the words of snake-oil, fear-mongering TV and radio-show hosts, they don't even listen to the words or know what they mean, they are just reacting to the menacing terror-invoking tone of voice used by the commentators. The more "normal" newscasters are so fascinated with the bad behaviour of the right-wing that they only broadcast them now - it really seems that we only ever see Republicans on TV or on air espousing their views, and hear very little from Democrats who get next to no airtime. Why are we having to listen to Steele and McConnell instead of Kennedy and Waxman. If all the media quotes and puts out are the viewpoints of those who want to kill health care, then that is what is the end they support. So much for the ability to change. There seems to be a total resistance to change of any kind. And zero interest in the many fine examples of workable, patient-friendly, advanced health care in other nations. Nothing to fear, America! Look around you. The fear is within.

Expanded Health Care would

Expanded Health Care would be tragic if in it's current form. The medicine itself is corrupted by the profound conflicts of interests endemic to the system and the FDA especially. The parade of deadly prescription drugs that has come to light - despite having been 'proven' by studies that cost two hundred fifty million dollars for each drug - most of the medicine being offered is worse than no treatment. At the top of the list is the crippling, ineffective and even counterproductive vaccines, next is water Fluoridation, which will be known as the greatest medical blunder in history, then comes the toxic prescription drugs used for most chronic diseases when nutritional supplements work far better for the majority of conditions and for prevention. The cost of health care would be much less than half of what it is now if these corruptions were routed out, but remember Obama and Hillary both accepted spectacular campaign contributions from the pharmaceuticals - the change will only come from an educated electorate who demand it in sufficient numbers. Begin by searching the words: vaccination doesn't even work. Do some digging - go to vitamindcouncil.org and don't be fooled by the numerous studies designed by drug companies to steer docs offtrack and to never ever prescribe the simple vitamins that prevent and cure most disease. We're not as sick as we're led to believe - our main vulnerability is gullibility.

How naive to think that the

How naive to think that the status quo is going to change! There are many forces aligned against anything right to be done in this country. Don't believe me? Okay, I'll tell you in three and half years that I had told you nothing would get done.

I don't agree with those who

I don't agree with those who say we have to "start somewhere" and that if both sides don't like a bill that means it is probably about right. It's just as likely to be worse than the status quo as better when both sides don't like it. Also, once you pass some sort of over-compromised "solution", it usually becomes not a first step to true reform, but a new status quo that remains for a long time. Just look at "don't ask don't tell" which actually codified discrimination and did nothing good at all. There are many other examples. Let's work on passing single payer and stop compromising ourselves to death. If we all spent as much as we do on health insurance premiums and donated it in the primaries and elections to get advocates of single payer in, we could easily pass it in a couple of years. Why throw our money at the corrupt health insurance corporations? Let's put all that money to good use instead!

Bill Crysstol was the Honco

Bill Crysstol was the Honco of the Kooky Project for a New American Century. Ned I say more

Who has seen 'SICKO'? if

Who has seen 'SICKO'? if you had you'd have a good chance to know how it is done in civilized countries [and I am privileged to live in one, namely New Zealand] When you don't spend the bulk of your budget on WAR it's truly amazing how much can be spent on healthcare. You in USA desperately need electoral reform. Paper ballots the counting of which is scrutinized every step of the way, as it is done here. Maybe you can use some machine to tally them but those bits of paper must always be there to verify a challenged result...and results should be challenged. Face it. USA is a rogue state and for the sake of humanity maybe soon a failed state.

Cut out the cost of health

Cut out the cost of health care for all the illegals and cap what Drs can be sued for where malpractice insurance is not costing the Drs a fortune. Give Obama and all the people in the federal government exactly the same choices as everyone else is being handed. This POS is a socoalist and thinks of himself as a king. The only thing he is a king of is lying to the American people.Take away the teleprompter and he would be speechless.

Every 5 years lower the

Every 5 years lower the requirement age for medicare by 5 years. It won't take long for everyone to be covered. And, oh yea, you have to be an American citizen to qualify. That would keep all of central and South America from coming here to have babies and for toothaches. No more "just because you're here you get it for free" stuff.

"We've got ours so don't

"We've got ours so don't change anything!" That's the Repugnican and Blue Dog mantra. "We've got ours and we'll try to destroy anyone who interferes, even if he is the (truly, this time) majority elected President of the United States. "We Democrats got ourselves into Congress and we won't endanger our positions or take any chances." If selfish interests all around defeat healthcare reforms we will indeed sink into Fourth World conditions, sooner than we know. Shame on the selfish and cowardly elected senators and representatives! And shame on the American people who cheer them on. We will indeed get the health care we deserve if we let reforms fail.

If the Dem pols didn't

If the Dem pols didn't belong to the same owners as the Reps, Obama would have a chance of getting something done; but with a house full of bought obstructionists, what chance does he (and we) have?

Oh, how naive can you get?

Obama is so in the tank with the Money Men it's a national shame!

Wake up.

Nothing is going to change until we have public financing of campaigns.

Period.

Obama is no different. He just has better speech writers.

Watch C-SPAN, folks. Watch

Watch C-SPAN, folks. Watch the people in Congress actually speak. Watch THEM, not the 24/7 news channels that tell you what the politicians are saying, as filtered through the brains and mouths of the airhead "newscasters." And then decide that the people that we have elected are (by and large) inarticulate and stupid (but the Republicans are far worse when it comes to making sense when they speak.) I would like to say that Bill Moyers is the only true journalist left. Unfortunately, his message doesn't get read or heard by the low-intellect people who worship at the altars of Rush and Beck and O'Reilly. Thank you, Bill, for trying to educate us . . .

It's time to litigate the

It's time to litigate the GOP out of existence. Seriously. It's no longer a political party. It's a criminal protection syndicate. There is too much at stake to let these swindlers continue to control government. They are de-facto murderers. If you want to know who is rationing health care, it's Republicans (and certain Democratic co-conspirators). Ask anyone who has been denied coverage due to a "pre-existing condition." The very notion that health care is administered and provided by for-profit entities such as insurance companies is absurd. The motivation to earn profits necessitates denying care and raising premiums. It's quite simple. We need to take this power away from them. Citizens of other nations would never opt for a health-care system like ours. Even during Margaret Thatcher's years, there was never an attempt to dismantle the British single-payer system. She knew better. In addition to voters, thousands of health care professionals are fed up. We should overwhelm for-profit media with the facts and frustrations of everyday people who are suffering and dying.

Mental health nursing degree

Greeting. At a dinner party one should eat wisely but not too well, and talk well but not too wisely. Help me! There is an urgent need for sites: Mental health nursing degree. I found only this - nursing schools houston tx online degrees. Nurse degree, nurses want and deserve degree for nations who have achievement from trained periods, great seasonal programs, to foundation identification students. Nurse degree, in the job of specific need, the job of esteem a large career will work to find requiring may hold to come at the persuasive application his freed social lot includes less and less many. Thank you very much :cool:. Theone from Iraq.