Share

Israel's Jerusalem Evictions Defy Obama, Undermine Peace Process

by: Dan Murphy  |  The Christian Science Monitor

photo
An Israeli policeman guards a house being renovated in east Jerusalem. (Photo: AFP / Getty Images)

    The international community objected strongly as Israel moved settlers in and longtime Palestinian residents out.

    Israel said the evictions were legal and mandated by a ruling of its supreme court. But the country's decision Sunday to forcibly remove two Palestinian families from their homes in East Jerusalem - and to immediately usher in Jewish replacements - has complicated the prospects for successful peace talks any time soon.

    On Monday, three people protesting the eviction were arrested by the police. The two families had lived in the homes for almost 50 years. They moved into the neighborhood after being evicted from their homes in West Jerusalem in 1947 by Israeli forces.

    Two families might not seem like much after a 50-year conflict that has displaced hundreds of thousands and cost countless lives. But they came in symbolically fraught East Jerusalem, where President Barack Obama has practically begged Israel to stop settlement expansion to give peace talks a chance. Israel annexed East Jerusalem in 1967 - a move that the international community has not accepted - and Palestinians hope the eastern portion of the city will one day form the capital of their own independent state.

    The images beamed around the region were a stark illustration of the Israeli-Palestinian divide as could be imagined: Israeli soldiers force distraught families from their homes and then stand guard as Orthodox Jewish settlers bring in moving vans and take possession (an Al Jazeera English video report on the event is here). The event will have likely deepened a growing Arab belief that Obama will not be more successful than his predecessors in advancing the peace process.

    The Times of London quoted chief Palestinian negotiator Saab Eraket as saying Israel was not committed to a renewed peace process. "While Israeli authorities have promised the American administration that home demolitions, home evictions, and other provocations against Palestinian Jerusalemites would be stopped, what we've seen on the ground is completely the opposite," he said. The paper also quoted an unusually stern statement from the British consulate in East Jerusalem.

"Israel's claim that the imposition of extremist Jewish settlers into this ancient Arab neighbourhood is a matter for the courts or the municipality is entirely unacceptable.... Their actions are incompatible with Israel's desire for peace. We urge Israel not to allow extremists to set the agenda."

    As we reported in July, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu effectively told the Obama administration to buzz off when it asked him to suspend settlement expansion in Jerusalem last month. That dispute was over the plans of American bingo magnate Irving Moskowitz, a major bankroller of settler activity, to convert a hotel he owns in East Jerusalem into apartments for settlers. Then, when Obama's Mideast peace envoy George Mitchell visited Jerusalem in late July to press again for a settlement freeze, 11 new settler outposts were set up in the West Bank.

    Moskowitz's hotel, like the houses seized on Sunday, lies in Sheikh Jarrah (a map of the area, with a rough idea of the Palestinian and Israeli breakdown, is here), a largely Palestinian neighborhood that is home to the famous American Colony hotel and has seen a number of evictions of Palestinians over the years in favor of religious Israeli settlers.

    Palestinians charge that the idea is to place enough Israelis in East Jerusalem, whose annexation by Israel has not been recognized internationally, to make it impossible for any compromises over sovereignty in the area to be made in a theoretical future peace deal. In particular they allege an effort to isolate the Palestinian community in Jerusalem's Old City from the heavily Palestinian northern neighborhoods of the city by taking control of Sheikh Jarrah, which would essentially cut the Palestinian community in East Jerusalem in half.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.

Support Truthout's work with a $10/month tax-deductible donation today!
Share         

»


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

It is obvious to all

It is obvious to all concerned that Israel will not seek peace and will continue with their horrific settlement and war program. Anything else said by Israel is BS. The only answer for the US is to IMMEDIATELY IF NOT SOONER CUT OFF ALL AID TO ISRAEL. No military supplies or money and no financial aid.. NOW. If the USA cannot see the writing on the wall, then the USA will continue to been seen as an "accomplice" in Israel's crimes against humanity.

When is something actually

When is something actually going to be DONE about these arrogant Israeli actions instead of merely condemning them? If the US government really wanted to move the peace process forward they could do so by threatening to withhold the annual US subsidy on millions of dollars to Israel, paid for by the US taxpayer. This might persuade those who disregard UN resolutions and international law to toe the line. Imagine what the reaction would be if it were Israelis who were being evicted from their homes by Palestinians. There would be cries of "Persecution", "Anti-Semitism", "Holocaust Mark 2" and so on.... How is it that the Israelis just get away with their insatiable demand for other people's land and homes , while the rest of the world does NOTHING! When is someone to start a boycott of Israeli produce? I would be the first to join!

I am so appalled at the

I am so appalled at the treatment of Palestinians by the Israelis and the fact that they get away with it. Various governments express their regret, but none do anything concrete to change the situation. If they really do want to better the lives of Palestinians and have justice prevail, they must stand up and say 'no more financial support for Israel until they stop behaving illegally'. That is the only way of influencing the Israeli government.

that's got to be one of the

that's got to be one of the more ignorant & arrogant headlines I've read lately. Like it or not, Israel is a sovereign nation--as is Iraq. Obama is not the president of Israel, nor is he the president or leader of Iraq. So, Israel isn't defying Obama, it's doing whatever it thinks best, however stupid & hurtful it might be. I sure hope that all of the commenters who are so angry about Israel's behavior are equally angry when a Palestinian bombs an Israeli area. No one is blameless in this conflict--and that includes all the Arab nations (& Egypt) who refuse to let Palestinians emigrate to their nations, but who do hire them as immigrant labor and treat them quite badly. Perhaps no one reading this article remembers that Kuwait expelled every single Palestinian in its borders after the first Gulf War. Yep, those Arab nations really stick together & help & protect "their own."

In response to a previous

In response to a previous comment, the fact that other Arab nations treat Palestinians badly does nothing to diminish Israel's wrongful actions. Two wrongs don't make a right. Those are sovereign nations as well who do not feel that Palestinians are their responsibility. Like it or not the Palestinian crisis is Israel's responsibility as are it's horrendous actions against them. It is an embarrassment for Jews everywhere.

Each time I read a comment

Each time I read a comment such as "that's got to be one of the..." I feel such despair. The ignorance is so great that it resembles brainwashing, in the sense of a complete education dedicated to the falsification of history and a despising of the Palestinian people, whose rights have been trampled on for over 60 years. Such nonsense is regurgitated daily by supporter of Israel's actions against the Palestinians. What can one do? There is no country that frightens me more than Israel, with their holier than thou righteousness. I live in Germany and am aware every day of the still evident extensive damage caused to neighbouring countries during the second world war. I see a similar long-term damage taking place, non-stop, in the Middle East through the arrogance and reactionary behaviour of successive Israeli governments and their supporters. There was clearly a heated discourse among Jews in Europe and the USA when the Zionists began moving to Palestine - it is being revived, but it is not enough!

I would be devastated if

I would be devastated if Israel did not exist, but equally strongly, I am devastated at the state of affairs. It makes me very sad. It suggests to me that it is time for the U.S. to use some of its considerable economic clout to "encourage" Israel to make some different decisions.

This is intolerable

This is intolerable behavior. The USA MUST stop giving ANY aid to Israel. They break every agreement and are abusive and racist toward Palestinians. They agreed to stop importing more settler and they've broken their promises. NO MORE UNACCOUNTABLE AID TO ISRAEL.

Israel owes its existence to

Israel owes its existence to a British Prime Minister (Balfour) and the sympathy felt by the world after the Nazi holocaust. Balfour was wrong; the Jews had (have) lived in the rest of the world (their Diaspora) for 2000 years and had mostly settled and assimilated in those countries. However, sympathy for persecuted minorities should not allow one to be deluded into being persuaded that Israel's behaviour is anything less than imperialist or that it could do as it does without the help of the United States. And the only thing the US is interested in is OIL. The Arabs have been shockingly abused by the Israelis, whose behaviour is in no way different from that of the Nazis towards the Jews - it is genocidal. Until Arabs and Jews can live side by side in places like Jerusalem, there can be no peace there. The Jews have no exclusive rights there (certainly no right to expel people who have lived there for many generations) and the Arabs need to learn to accept a mixed community based on common humanity, regardless of belief or race. Bigotry is being used to advance the interests of American profits, here and elsewhere in the Middle East (incidentally, used not this area to be called the "Near East"?).

You have an ignorant and

You have an ignorant and one-sided version of the story. See here: http://jewishrefugees.blogspot.com/2009/11/jewish-rights-ignored-in-jerusalem.html