Share

Real "Norma Rae" Dies of Cancer After Insurer Delayed Treatment

by: Sue Sturgis  |  Facing South

photo
A screenshot of Sally Field in the film "Norma Rae." The North Carolina union organizer who inspired the movie died on Friday of brain cancer. (Photo: shavawnmarie / Flickr)

    The North Carolina union organizer who was the inspiration for the movie "Norma Rae" died on Friday of brain cancer after a battle with her insurance company, which delayed her treatment. She was 68.

    Crystal Lee Sutton, formerly Crystal Lee Jordan, was fired from her job folding towels at the J.P. Stevens textile plant in her hometown of Roanoke Rapids, N.C. for trying to organize a union in the early 1970s. Her last action at the plant -- writing the word "UNION" on a piece of cardboard and standing on her work table, leading her co-workers to turn off their machines in solidarity -- was memorialized in the 1979 film by actress Sally Field. The police physically removed Sutton from the plant for her action.

    But her efforts ultimately succeeded, as the Amalgamated Clothing Workers won the right to represent the plant's employees on Aug. 28, 1974. Sutton later became a paid organizer for the union, which through a series of mergers became part of UNITE HERE before splitting off this year to form Workers United, which is affiliated with the Service Employees International Union.

    Several years ago, Sutton was diagnosed with meningioma, a type of cancer of the nervous system. While such cancers are typically slow-growing, Sutton's was not -- and she went two months without potentially life-saving medication because her insurance wouldn't cover it initially. Sutton told the Burlington (N.C.) Times-News last year that the insurer's behavior was an example of abuse of the working poor:

    "How in the world can it take so long to find out [whether they would cover the medicine or not] when it could be a matter of life or death," she said. "It is almost like, in a way, committing murder."

    Though Sutton eventually received the medication, the cancer had already taken hold. She passed away on Friday, Sept. 11 in a Burlington, N.C. hospice.

    "Crystal Lee Sutton was a remarkable woman whose brave struggles have left a lasting impact on this country and without doubt, on me personally," Field said in a statement released Friday. "Portraying Crystal Lee in 'Norma Rae,' however loosely based, not only elevated me as an actress, but as a human being."

    Field won an Oscar, a Golden Globe and the Best Actress award at the Cannes Film Festival for her portrayal of the character based on Sutton. The film in turn was based on the 1975 book "Crystal Lee: A Woman of Inheritance" by New York Times reporter Henry P. "Hank" Leiferman.

    Sutton was only 17 when she began working at the J.P. Stevens plant in northeastern North Carolina, where conditions were poor and the pay was low. A Massachusetts-based company that for many years was listed on the Fortune 500, J.P. Stevens is now part of the WestPoint Home conglomerate.

    In 1973, Sutton, by then a mother of three, was earning only $2.65 an hour. That same year, Eli Zivkovich, a former coal miner from West Virginia, came to Roanoke Rapids to organize the plant and began working with Sutton, who was fired after she copied a flyer posted by management warning that blacks would run the union. It was that incident which led Sutton to stand up with her "UNION" sign.

    "It is not necessary I be remembered as anything, but I would like to be remembered as a woman who deeply cared for the working poor and the poor people of the U.S. and the world," she said in a newspaper interview last year. "That my family and children and children like mine will have a fair share and equality."

    For more on Sutton's life and work, visit the website of the Alamance Community College's Crystal Sutton Collection.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.

Support Truthout's work with a $10/month tax-deductible donation today!
  

»


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

Thank you, Ms Sutton.

Thank you, Ms Sutton. That's what I call making a difference. And thank you, Ms Sturgis, for passing on the poignant coda to her truth-teller's life. Murder, indeed.

Once again, "Norma Rae"

Once again, "Norma Rae" stirs the heart to action.

And they lobby yet today to

And they lobby yet today to murder the working poor...and especially those unable to.

Of course it's murder. But

Of course it's murder. But from the insurance industry's point of view it's probably slaughter, since that industry regards us the way the meat-packing industry regards feed-lot animals. Both industries make their profits from death. "Get along, get along, get along, little doggies It's your misfortune, And none of my own" as the old cowboy song goes. Mary

And the answer is more

And the answer is more private insurance, no public option, and taxpayers subsidizing private insurance payments? Do we really think private for-profit insurance companies will insure everyone, even with pre-existing conditions, for reasonable rates, and pay for the care needed by everyone without the sorts of delays and other maneuvers that Crystal endured?

Here's a woman who has

Here's a woman who has worked all her life in conditions of third world squalor, and yet was sentenced to an early death by unthinking, uncaring bureaucrats in a greedy, immoral insurance company. Idiots and corrupt politicians are out there, protesting the attempt to provide insurance coverage to folks who traditionally have been used by insurers, their premiums taken but treatments denied. Both my Senators, Pryor and Lincoln, as well as my Congressman, Mike Ross, belong to those idiots and corrupt politicos. Does yours? Call them. Protest. Threaten to fire them. DO SOMETHING.

This story is being repeated

This story is being repeated across the country. And yet, an organized 10,000 (???) loonies milled around Washington this past weekend, trying to make sure it would continue. The fat cat Repugnican "leadership" is insulated from it all. Those self-rightous folk need not worry. They have health care benefits that include no waiting period and no pre-existing conditions clause for themselves and their dependents, 75% of the tab paid for them by the taxpayers, prescription service and emergency care RIGHT AT THE WORKPLACE. But, of course, they won't let the rest of us have such a "welfare" program. And they are earning far more than the average American. THEY ARE THE LIARS, and yet they sit smugly while one of their own shouts the "L" word at the President of the United States, on national television. Those who were in on the plans ahead of time should be called out and shamed.

The headline should

The headline should be "Insurance Company Death Panel kills workers' rights icon" At the age of 51, I was diagnosed with colon cancer and promptly treated. Luckily I had employer insurance and a desk job that I could do while chemotherapy made me too weak to do any physical job. Most people would have lost their job, and their insurance, and their treatment, and like Norma Rae, their life.

This is a tragedy, for sure,

This is a tragedy, for sure, but can we be certain that changing to a new system will make health care available more swiftly? Adding 50 million bodies into a system with no more doctors and hospitals will surely tax any system. And even more relevant - since you speak of the working poor - is the question of whether health care be the same for the rich and the poor? I doubt that working stiffs will have access to the level of health care that is subsidized by our taxes for government workers all the way up to the president.

It would be helpful to know

It would be helpful to know the name of the insurance company. Jaguar

So there we have it. The

So there we have it. The real "death panels" are not those of Obama - but the Private Insurance Companies. And this wasn't "granny" who died: this was someone who had a hard time with business bosses all her life.

under obamacare, at age 68,

under obamacare, at age 68, with her productive years behind her, she would have been last in line for healthcare. Government running anything is not the answer

When Ted Kennedy was

When Ted Kennedy was diagnosed with brain cancer, did the insurance company he has delay his treatment or medication? More than likely NOT! Why? Because it appears our elected officials deserve superior health insurance while the working class deserve to fight for their right to treatment and medication, especially if it may save a life. Do our Human Resource departments and its employees fight for the rights of the workers for fair and equal rights? Again, more than likely NOT! When is this unethical treatment going to stop? President Obama is working very hard to change these situations so that everyone is eligible to receive the same benefits our elected officials have been entitled. Now is the time to support the person who knows how to get things done! Let's get fired up and ready to go to support him in his efforts. Why? Because we ALL deserve the same rights as others and this is the time to stop the insurance companies from committing such offenses to those in dire need.

Capitalism kills people in

Capitalism kills people in favor of the all mighty dollar on a regular basis. Capitalism fails people where it wins profits. Greedy corporate executives will kill you for what they want. Democracy is one person one vote where all votes carry the same weight. Capitalism is one person picks up all the dollars. The two systems are not the same thing. Fight back...Loyalty to our cause, we must not tolerate their obstruction.

What was the name of the

What was the name of the insurance company? Not that one is better than another, but they dexerve to be named.

In Ms. Sutton's memory, let

In Ms. Sutton's memory, let us spread the story of her fate far and wide and call her executioners by name: insurance companies devoted to profit and greed, not people. The public option is not enough. We need the single payer plan. It's not perfect -- not close -- but it's far and away better than what we have now. Ask anyone from Canada or the UK.

Let's hope Obama gets us

Let's hope Obama gets us health care. Look what happens when the insurance companies are in charge. They get to choose who lives and dies by dragging their feet. If the Federal Government capped drugged prices and purchased them in bulk-like Canada- these meds would have been available to one of our true American Hero's. It does not matter which insurance company did this, Insurance Companies ALL do this, postpone medication and procedures knowing it will cause death all the sooner. WE NEED UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE! -I have brain cancer, I have been denied care and am appealing to my insurance provider...don't know if I'll survive to the appeal date. Peace out.

That insurance companies can

That insurance companies can deny care should give people much to complain about and DEMAND universal health care, public option if not single payer. I can't believe that the people that precisely need health care are the ones that are rallying to Glenn Beck's encouragement. Fools are born every minute.

She was 68? Didn't she also

She was 68? Didn't she also have Medicare?

To Anonymous with brain

To Anonymous with brain cancer ~ I wish you wellness and life in your battle, not only with the disease, but with your insurance company. I truly hope you get the treatment necessary very soon. And thank you for being brave enough to put your illness out there for all to be aware. Keep up the fight, for the battle you win may be your own! God Bless!!

I was sickened by the news

I was sickened by the news that Crystal was denied medication that would have helped her by the Insurance companies quest for profits. We need to get these vampires out of our medical system. I hope that the bill from the Max Bacus Republican Trojan horse panel is trashed and real health care reform comes forth. They just sabotaged any real reform from the beginning. I devoted my latest weekly cartoon, to the memory of Crystal Lee Sutton and her insurance company death panel! www.whatnowtoons.com

I thought medicare covered

I thought medicare covered people over 65? My penniless dad got cancer at 71 and got prompt, expensive, extensive treatment that gave him ten more years, all paid for by medicare.

Unfortunately, the problem

Unfortunately, the problem with many insurance companies is not just health care, but also when you are in an accident. If interested see my blog post: http://myalabamainjurylawyer.com

It would be helpful to know

It would be helpful to know the name of the drug or treatment she was denied. Many of these so-called lifesaving drugs are not. It is hype and marketing. Fear-mongering to have the public demanding they get the drug, which does nothing for the ill, but pads the coffers of the very people you see as your healhcare enemies. Find out before you assume.