Share

Nobel Committee, Strategic as Ever, Taps Obama for Peace Prize

by: Robert Naiman, t r u t h o u t | News Analysis

Nobel Peace Prize.
In a surprise announcement, US President Barack Obama was awarded the Nobel Prize for Peace. (Photo: nobelprize.org)

    The Norwegian Nobel Committee has awarded the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize to President Obama.

    Some initial commentary has called the award unprecedented and wondered why the committee would give President Obama the award when he "hasn't done anything yet."

    But anyone who thinks this award is unprecedented hasn't been paying attention.

Also see below:     
President Obama Wins Nobel Peace Prize    β€’

    The Nobel Committee gave South African Bishop Desmond Tutu the Nobel Peace Prize in 1984 for his leadership efforts to abolish apartheid in South Africa. Apartheid wasn't fully abolished in South Africa until 1994. The committee could have waited until after apartheid was abolished to say, "Well done!" But the point of the award was to help bring down apartheid by strengthening Bishop Tutu's efforts. In particular, everyone knew that it was going to be much harder for the apartheid regime to crack down on Tutu after the Nobel Committee wrapped him in its protective cloak of world praise.

    That's what the Nobel Committee is trying to do for Obama now. It's giving an award to encourage the change in world relations that Obama has promised, and to try to help shield Obama against his domestic adversaries. The committee is well aware that history is contingent and that Obama might fail. It knows very well that the same country that elected Obama also gave the world George W. Bush and Ronald Reagan.

    The initial steps that Obama has taken are already under fierce attack. The Obama administration has now recognized that the Afghan Taliban are not a threat to the United States and that the United States can live with the Afghan Taliban playing a role in the government of Afghanistan. But right-wing forces in the military, Congress, think tanks and the media are denouncing these moves toward sanity as surrender. They want a full-out Vietnam against the Taliban.

    The Obama administration has begun its promised diplomatic engagement with Iran. Of course, as every honest person knew, real engagement meant de-emphasizing the unachievable demand that Iran end its enrichment of uranium and instead focusing on achievable demands like opening Iranian enrichment facilities more fully to UN inspections and greater international oversight over the enriched uranium that Iran has already produced. Here also, the "endless war" right-wing is trying to undermine Obama.

    In giving this award, the Nobel Committee is telling these right-wing forces to back off. And it's sending a message of encouragement to those Americans who put Obama in office:

"Showing signs of significant improvement. Keep up the good work."

 :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

President Obama Wins Nobel Peace Prize

by: Steven Thomma  |  Visit article original @ McClatchy Newspapers

    Washington - President Barack Obama won the Nobel Peace Prize, it was announced Friday, making him the first American president to win the award in his first year.

    Despite his brief tenure on the job and lack of tangible achievements yet, the Nobel Committee said it honored Obama "for his extraordinary efforts to strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between peoples."

    "Only very rarely has a person to the same extent as Obama captured the world's attention and given its people hope for a better future," said Nobel chairman Thorbjoern Jagland.

    Obama was notified of the surprise award at about 6 a.m. in a call from Press Secretary Robert Gibbs. Obama planned to make a statement in the White House Rose Garden at 10:30 EDT.

    Obama becomes the fourth American president to win the award and the third to win while in office.

    Theodore Roosevelt won the 1906 prize after personally interceding to negotiate a peace between Japan and Russia. Roosevelt brought the two sides to New Hampshire in September 1905 and helped negotiate a peace treaty after several weeks.

    Woodrow Wilson won the 1919 prize after he pushed to create the League of Nations following World War I, traveling to Europe to personally negotiate. The U.S. Senate ultimately rejected the U.S. role, however.

    After leaving office, Jimmy Carter won the 2002 prize for what the committee called decades of work. As president, Carter personally brought Egypt and Israel together for weeks of talks at Camp David, Maryland, that produced a peace deal. As an ex-president, he's traveled the globe trying to promote human rights and mediate disputes.

    Obama has no comparable accomplishments. He has urged peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians but has so far been rebuffed. His one measurable achievement has been to improve the U.S. standing in the world as measured by polls in foreign countries, particularly after reaching out to the Muslim world in several speeches, including one from Cairo, Egypt.

    "The prize signals that America is definitively back in the world's good graces and the President deserves full credit for that," said Martin Indyk, Vice President and Director for Foreign Policy at the Brookings Institution, a former official in the Clinton administration.

    "Now comes the hard part: turning goodwill into concrete results that can heal the wounds of a very troubled world. If Obama can do that he'll deserve another Nobel."

    The prize was a surprise even at the White House.

    "It's an honor. It's nothing anyone expected. It's certainly nothing the president sought," senior adviser David Axelrod said on MSNBC. "I think that he's less interested in individual honors and this certainly is one than in advancing the causes that the were cited by the Nobel committee."

    Axelrod also said it was not known if Obama would travel to Oslo, Norway, to personally accept the award.

    "This is all news to us," he said, "so I don't know what we're going to do with regards to that. I would assume so, but I don't know."

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.

Support Truthout's work with a $10/month tax-deductible donation today!
Share         

»


Robert Naiman is senior policy analyst at Just Foreign Policy.

Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

This makes even less sense

This makes even less sense than Kissinger's Peace Prize. Obama wants to increase the size of the military, continue the war in Iraq, expand the wars in Afghanistan and Pakistan, has been a grudging follower in the international campaign to restore democracy in Honduras. He's done nothing but talk about nuclear disarmament or Palestine. Why should we want to encourage this with praise?

So what you're saying is

So what you're saying is that it's just fine to conduct three wars, murder countless civilians, children included, continue Bush's legacy of secret torture and still earn the Nobel Peace Prize because peace is "on the horizon." I've not known one U.S. President, including Truman, who did not ceaselessly talk about accomplishing peace. I can see no evidence of dawning peace in this Obama administration. Quite the contrary, in fact. This is a purely political gesture, though, that might have some positive electoral repercussions. At its very least, it's a knife in the back of the Republicans. At least we can enjoy their humiliation in this Nobel gesture.

A joke. The man who

A joke. The man who continues two wars and even escalates one of them is given a "peace" prize? The fix is in.

Excellent news, and well

Excellent news, and well deserved. The change Obama has brought to this country and the world in his few months in office have changed our outlook and the opinion of the world toward the better, more peaceful and hopeful. The Nobel Peace Prize is an honor acknowledged around the world. It is recognition of unusual accomplishment, and its award to our President should be celebrated by all Americans, not only those of good will. Congratulations, Mr. President. Congratulations, America.

Holy crap Batman! To award

Holy crap Batman! To award the peace prize to someone who is expanding the neo-con wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, and continuing with the pro-Israeli stance and support of their ethnic cleansing in Palestine and Israel. And the saber rattling over Iran's efforts to have a single nuclear weapon while ignoring the hundreds presently in Israel's arsenal is not the action of a peace loving president. Where is the support for the democratically elected president of Honduras, where is the move to end the 5 decade long embargo with Cuba, and where is the move to provide a reduction in the USA military spending that fuels the war machine of our military industrial complex?

Isn't Obama for war in

Isn't Obama for war in Afghanistan? Then I guess Alfred Nobel must be rolling in his grave with Obama so called accomplishment? Did Nobel say the award must go to "to the person who shall have done the most or the best work for fraternity between the nations and the abolition or reduction of standing armies and the formation and spreading of peace congresses." ???? I am confused?

i find some comments to be

i find some comments to be obnoxious. The man has boosted efforts at diplomacy and had the U.N. unanimously decide to rid the world of nuclear weapons. He is pulling out of Iraq in 16 months, opposes torture, and it was the guys controlling the drones who killed civilians, it's unfair to say that he did it. Yes, he has made mistakes, who hasn't?

Supplement to my previous

Supplement to my previous comment: If Obama has any "class," he will decline the award in favour of those who have suffered under HIS policies of ramping up the war begun by Mad King George! He will cite the numerous "unnamed" persons all over the world who have spoken out against the militaristic "programmes" and "schemes" undertaken by the ALL the wingnut Heads of State! Such an action would give greater credibility to his announced "beliefs" and efforts to bring about a more peaceful world!!!

Sorry to keep adding to what

Sorry to keep adding to what I've said previously. . .Re: the award to Desmond Tutu. . .Bishop Tutu had a track record of DECADES fighting apartheid (Not to mention the years of incarceration because of his efforts!) Mr Naiman. . .a poor analogy!

I was going to comment about

I was going to comment about the derision on the right wing blogs this morning, but I see they have arrived here as well. And while I agree that Obama hasn't done much yet, I believe that's a function of the politics of governing with that pesky party of NO hanging around. Obama and his followers were probably naive to think bipartisanship would follow if he made a real effort to include the GOP. Instead we see their real goal is bring down the Democrats at any cost, even if it hurts the USA.

Peace prizes are obviously

Peace prizes are obviously awarded based on mysterious formulae having nothing whatsoever to do with peace or accomplishment of any kind.

This must be 1984....War is

This must be 1984....War is peace. Freedom is slavery. Ignorance is strength. The Nobel committee has succumbed to Orwellian 'doublespeak'. It is indeed a woeful state of affairs when the man who said he would end war is rewarded with the prize for peace even as he continues and even escalates war....

Yasser Arafat got the prize,

Yasser Arafat got the prize, too.

Let's see, should we give

Let's see, should we give the Peace Prize to Gandhi or Hitler? We can't decide. Let's give it to Obama.

The deadline for peace prize

The deadline for peace prize nominations was February 1st, by which time Obama had been in office for ten days. He should have declined. This is going to leave an "affirmative action" kind of bad taste in many people's mouths. One bright spot, though – it’ll make it that much harder for him to attack Iran.

Truly, "a prophet is without

Truly, "a prophet is without honor in his own country."

If Iran blows up Israel,

If Iran blows up Israel, does he have to give it back?

The GOP has hindered every

The GOP has hindered every step Obama has wanted to take. There should be a booby prize and it should go to the Republican Party

WE ARE LIVING IN

WE ARE LIVING IN '1984'.......war is peace... If you haven't read '1984' you ought to. Then realize this was written in 1948. Orwell didn't dream this stuff up, people in the communist party told him of plans to infiltrate and break America up. The four parts were education, religion, science, and politics. Schools are dumbed down, religions are coming 'together' as one. Science is distorted to be used by the corporations for money. Politics? In order to have two parties you must have two different policies, we don't. We are only led to believe have two parties, keeps us thinking we have democracy. It is all the same no matter who is in office. Nothing makes sense anymore and that is by design. It is all 'double speak', And if you are confused or depressed take your anti-depression, or your viagra. Realize this 'redistribution' is among the world, not America. The global banking cartel is splitting up the goods, and soon the physical property. The Army National Guard site is now hiring 'Internment / Relocation Specialist', they need 67,000. If you are hungry there is a job for you. (go to there site if you need to check). When people are hungry they will work for the destroyers. And people are getting becoming hungry and homeless! It is all by design. How else could all the dots connect from 1948- 1984-2009-.. Why can things pass without elected officials being allowed to even read them? Wake up. check the sites, MAJOR changes things put into place with false flag 9-11 architects and engineers for 911 truth, firefighters for 911 truth.org, pilots for 911 truth.

President Obama really has

President Obama really has changed the attitudes in the World in a few short months. Iran has agreed to futher talks. North Korea has agreed to further talks. Russia seems to be working with us. The Chinese have indicated that they will work on Global Climate Change -- and they can actually do it because they don't have a Congress to deal with. President Obama has literally changed the World we live in. I'm proud of him and I'm proud of us for electing him.

Or maybe they gave him the

Or maybe they gave him the prize for pulling the U.S. back, for at least a couple of minutes, from the brink of fascism?

I am not a Republican nor a

I am not a Republican nor a Democrat ( I'm one of the few independents!!) but I think giving an award of such prestige to a standing president who has yet to achieve anything other than being just better than George W. Bush is quite naive at best. Setting the bar to that level of prestige will not only tarnish the award even further than before but endanger the sacred ceremony of peace to someone who has not achieved anything. In fact, I think it is best used for people like Hu Jia, Dr. Denis Mukwege, Wei Jingsheng or even to an organization called " Handicap International and Cluster Munition Coalition ". I fear that rewarding to a political figure during his tenure as president will create fissures and fracture the entire country that is already so weakened to begin with. I am just not at all pleased with the selection process by the Nobel Committee by making a political statement rather than giving the Nobel Peace Prize to any of the people that I have listed here. I am sorry but I do not accept this as a achievement for Obama but at best a set back to further peace. ( To note again strongly, I am not a Republican nor a Democrat just your average hard working independent American with no political affiliation)

It seems to me that the

It seems to me that the Nobel Committee has set down a marker for the needed accomplishments in world politics in the near future, and dedicated it to a leader committed to achieve and likely to accomplish them, as evidenced by the obvious fact that he is already working at meeting several of its terms.

Un-friggin' believable. Are

Un-friggin' believable. Are they sure they didn't want to give it "W"? Nothing has changed. We are STILL in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Honduras. The only thing that has changed is the rhetoric. I bet the Iraqis and the Afghans are all celebrating the PEACE they've received.

Obama has been the human

Obama has been the human shield, standing up for decency, even when idiots yell out liar, and bully their way through government and town hall meetings. How dare you expect that in nine months he could turn around the Titanic of mismanagement in the White House for decades. Allow the man to be a human being. I think he WILL show his way, as a maker of Peace, and a return to country that regards people over profits. I don't agree with all of his appointments and everything he has done, but I am proud of him, and ask others to not be so short sighted. He cannot succeed if he is blasted on both sides.BE THE CHANGE YOU WANT TO SEE!

Obama won his senatorial

Obama won his senatorial seat being against the invasion of Iraq at a time when Bush et al might have pressured Mother Teresa into invading that country. Sure he's held the ship n' sails with what he's inherited. He recognizes that the Taliban's leaders hit the U.S. on 9/11 and we must not let that happen again. He's called for nuclear disarmament, he's talked down the war in Iraq but refuses to cowtow to the world though he knows it was wrong but in a bigger way that terrorism is what we are fighting. Kudo's to the Norwegians for recognizing a man who can and will be greater peace and a negotiating mentality vs. the wrongful war criminal politics of the Republican Party under Bush that they so wrongfully flaunted for 8 years to their political gain and our moral loss on the world stage.

Obama is turning out to be a

Obama is turning out to be a great president. He has already set the world on a new path toward cooperation.

President Obama is trying to

President Obama is trying to get us out of Afghanistan. Many of the comments on this article are unfair to him. At last we have a president with intelligence.

The Nobel Peace Prize is a

The Nobel Peace Prize is a great honor for our President and for the American people. I have new hope for the future because of President Obama.

It is foolish to think that

It is foolish to think that we Americans revere or even care slightly about the Nobel Peace Prize. Just like what was done when Gore won, the media will be all too happy to rail against this award by making ad hominem attacks on the prize committee. Americans have an uncanny ability to vilify and dishonor even the most idealistic and morally upright people, institutions, and ideas as is politically convenient.

Just wait till he wins a

Just wait till he wins a Grammy for reading from a teleprompter

RE Fri, 10/09/2009 - 18:25

RE Fri, 10/09/2009 - 18:25 β€” Anonymous (not verified) You said... "and it was the guys controlling the drones who killed civilians" Ahhh Isn't the President controlling the guys who are controlling the drones who killed civilians? Where does the buck stop?

Well, I never thought the

Well, I never thought the Nobel Peace Prize committee could top the idiotic move to award the prize to Al-the-fraud Gore, but they did it. They have degraded this formerly prestigious award so much that is should probably be renamed the Nobel "Piece of S..t" Prize.

The Nobel Peace Prize ought

The Nobel Peace Prize ought to be renamed the Nobel Violence Prize and then Obama would deserve the 'honor'.

Actually, Bob, it was

Actually, Bob, it was Al-Qaeda (allegedly) that carried out 9-11. The Taliban offered to hand them over, and were refused. BTW, "terrorism" is just a tactic -- you can't fight it. Interesting that you take your usage from the Bush lexicon.

The mindless criticisms here

The mindless criticisms here are pathetic. No, we're not out of Iraq yet but did you read the recent article in NYT about the problem of getting all of our equipment out of the country? Would you prefer we just walk out and leave everything there? Wouldn't Alqueda love that? Just like when Bush left all the ammunition dumps unguarded after the invasion. This is just one example of the horrible mess left for Obama to clean up. Then think about the failure at Tora Bora and the ensuing mess in Afghanistan. And on and on. You think all this can be solved in a few months? Especially when EVERYTHING you try to do is met with mindless opposition from those who caused all this mess in the first place.

I didn't expect so much

I didn't expect so much vitriol on Truthout against this President. We have been poisoned by many of the pundits who fill the airwaves and have failed to see what Obama has tried to do. For the first time in a long time, I am proud to be an American. I am proud that my President is seen as an inspiring leader by the leaders of other countries. If we fail to see what he stands for or is trying to do, the fault may be more with us than with this man. I applaud the choice and am appalled by some of the comments found here.

Rachel Maddow showed clips

Rachel Maddow showed clips of some of the things Obama did in his first month, and I was amazed. At first I couldn't understand what he did to deserve this prize, but he actually has done quite a bit to promote peace. The biggest for me is getting countries to be serious again about reducing nuclear weapon stockpiles and material.

First of all I am not

First of all I am not spewing hate against Obama just the selection process of what the Nobel Peace Prize Commission has send out an entirely wrong signal. This will certainly divide our country when we seriously need to focus on domestic policies and international policies as well. This prize is probably more of a double edge sword to Obama rather than an advantage to use for making any progress. In fact, the Nobel SHOULD have gone to at least to Ghandi or any political oppressed individuals in their respective countries. I do not like ANY people on this forum who would EVEN think that Obama does even deserve this. This will ONLY create a more fractured country that will be divided into factionalism. I fear that this country will go down even further from today and I probably do not want to see the end of the tunnel from all of this.

I really am dumbfounded and

I really am dumbfounded and saddened by those who somehow see our American President berated in the press and in these comments for merely winning an award that he did not seek, but nonetheless justly deserves. The Republican talking point that President Obama was only in office for a matter of days is irrelevant because there is no requirement that you be in an elected office to win the Nobel Peace Prize, and The Change I Believe In started during the long campaign when President Obama won over the electorate and the rest of the world to boot. Ironic how W said "you are either with us or you are against us" and ultimately made America a virtual pariah in the world community and now the whole world is with Obama except for the Taliban and one-third of old, white America that represents what is left of the Republican Neo-Con Party of No.

The sickos who are ramping

The sickos who are ramping up the hate machines against the (FINALY!) duly elected President of the United States are showing their bigotry and narrow mindedness. The Nobel Committee is showing its understanding of the global desire for peace and the global hope that, once again, the United States can become a nation of laws and a beacon of and leader for peace. But no one can undo in a half-year what the high crimes and misdemeanors of the Bush/Cheney regime have brought about. I pray that our president can use the bully pulpit toward peace and renewal, and that the anti-anything-Obama crowd can wake up to what each of us must do to help make that a reality.