Share

Health Care Hypocrites

by: Jim Hightower, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

photo
Sen. Jim DeMint (R-South Carolina) has threatened to make health care reform "Obama's Waterloo." (Photo: gte333f / flickr)

How do you spell "hypocrisy"?

Try this: "H-Y-P-O-C-O-N-G-R-E-S-S." The hypocongress consists of those Republicans and Blue Dog Democrats who have risen up on their hind legs in recent weeks to snarl and howl at any mention of a government role in meeting America's health care needs. "Socialism," they bark -- we won't allow Barack Obama and the liberals to create a Washington-run, big-government intrusion into the hallowed private market. Sen. Jim DeMint, a South Carolina Republican, even pledged to fight so ferociously that the health care battle would be Obama's "Waterloo."

What a stand-up guy for free enterprise! What an ideologically correct appeal to laissez-faire principle! And, let me add, what a crock!

What these bellicose market-purists hope you don't discover is that they are closet socialists. As members of the congressional elite, they and their families are governmentally blessed with their very own gold-plated, taxpayer-financed, Washington-run health care system. And, they loooove it.

Theirs is such an effective system that not a single member of the hypocongress has been willing to give it up -- even though they surely realize the political peril of being exposed as rank hypocrites for enjoying the very program they so adamantly reject for you.

Actually, they happily take a double dip in the soothing waters of public health care. First, they enroll their entire families in the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program -- and you probably would, too, if it were available to you, for it's the Rolls Royce of health plans.

For example, while even the best employer-provided health policies offer only one or two types of coverage, FEHBP is a Chinese menu, offering dozens of coverage choices that allow its lucky members to assemble a plan that meets their unique needs. Members also need not worry about being denied coverage because of some pre-existing condition -- once sworn into office, lawmakers and their families are immediately and fully insured, with total access to a national network of doctors and hospitals.

But here's the sweetest part of their Rolls Royce ride: up to 75 percent of the premiums are paid for by taxpayers, many of whom are lucky if they can afford to buy an old Yugo-level of health coverage in the vaunted private market.

Well, snaps the hypocongress crowd, even if FEHBP is essentially government-paid insurance, at least it's not socialized medicine, with doctors working for the government -- so, technically, we're still pure.

Ah, that raises the second bit of secret socialism that lawmakers have mandated for themselves. Right under the Capitol dome, conveniently situated between the Senate and House chamber, is the Office of the Attending Physician. Inside are more than a dozen navy doctors, nurses, medical technicians, pharmacists and other health professionals, all employed by the government solely to attend to a select clientele: the 535 members of Congress.

Let's say that, after giving a fiery speech on the floor assailing the evils of government-run health care, a lawmaker gets gaseous or has a tongue cramp. He or she can pop right into the OAP for -- yes! -- some government-run health care. No appointment needed, no pesky insurance forms to fill out, no co-pay -- just care.

For this, members pay a flat fee of $503 a year. A year! You and I are taxed to cover the real costs of this elite service. And that's not the end of public health benefits for lawmakers -- if they need a specialist, an operation, therapy, rehab or other pricey procedure, it's all free at the government's Walter Reed and Bethesda Naval hospitals.

If it's good enough for them, why not us? The public deserves what the Congress has, and any member who opposes extending it to us should automatically be stripped of their privileges.

For a model of integrity, they might look to Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, and Rep. Steve Kagen, D-Wis. -- both of whom have rejected taking congressional coverage until everyone in America has coverage of equal quality. I don't think the noisy naysayers are looking for integrity, however -- not as long as they can get away with their abominable hypocrisy.

Copyright 2009 Creators.com

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.

Support Truthout's work with a $10/month tax-deductible donation today!
  

»


Columnist, national radio commentator, public speaker and author of the forthcoming book, "Swim Against The Current: Even a Dead Fish Can Go With the Flow," Jim Hightower has spent three decades battling the Powers That Be on behalf of the Powers That Ought To Be - consumers, working families, environmentalists, small businesses and just-plain-folks.

Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

The worst hypocrit is our

The worst hypocrit is our own president. Obama campaigned for universal health care and spoke against requiring everyone to purchase private insurance. Yet that is what we are about to get - a bailout of the private, for profit insurance industry via a purchase mandate. An industry that can collude to keep its prices high due to anti-trust exemption. President Obama has made secret deals with big pharma and seems content to let the public option die. This is the worst betrayal of the middle class in history - a bill to make the federal government the "enforcer" for the health insurance industry, public interest be damned!

I gotta deal for Senate

I gotta deal for Senate Republicans and Blue Dogs: Let's pass universal health care. In return, we'll privatize the other government run, heavily subsidised insurance programs: Federal Flood Insurance and Federal Crop Insurance. Putting our resorces to protect something so essential as public health makes sense, as does allowing the private market to serve other, less essential, insurance needs.

Hypocrisy is right. Those

Hypocrisy is right. Those Senators and Congressmen who vote against a public option are bought off cronies of the insurance lobby. They have been feeding at the public trough all this time, and they go home to their government funded health care plans. They never have to worry about whether or not they will be taken care of medically, or if they will have to file for bankruptcy due to catastrophic illness. It is time for a public option for the public and the anti trust exemption for insurance companies needs to be repealed.

Did you leave off the last

Did you leave off the last "e" for savings? (in hypocrite) No, while he may be a hypocrite, he is hardly the worst. That would be every Republican and Blue Dog as stated. They call Obama socialist, they claim without a shred of proof that he has a secret agenda. Yes, the bill sucks a big one, the one out of the Finance Committee, but I personally choose Ms. Snowe, Senator of Maine as the biggest liar and double-talker. For 8 years under Bush she protested, sounding like a liberal on this issue, coming out for public option, etc. But now she reverses course, I presume to power trip. Coming from a state and an araa with far more public health coverage and plans and legislation than most anywhere else in the country, well I vote for her as biggest hypocrite.

I'm befuddled about the

I'm befuddled about the response of progressive organizations that have been fighting hard for health care reform. So far, the response is we should thank Harry Reid, the Dems and Obama for a "public option" that will cover about 10% of the American public. Reid's version will cover only in states that DO NOT opt out and people who DO NOT have coverage. Even if the coverage they have is inadequate or too costly. It's a joke. Poll after poll shows that the Public wants the public option. A majority of the public. So who are these ELECTED representatives representing? Am I wrong?

I have sat here reading

I have sat here reading about the various plans submitted to both the House and the Senate, the interference by Sebelius in killing the public option or universal health care with her remarks, the negotiations by Rahm Emanuel and his staff with Big Pharma and the insurance industry not to mention the Blue Dog Democrats. I am sick at the way this bill is coming together as a gift-wrapped legacy to the insurance industry. Ted Kennedy must be rolling in his grave at this travesty of his wishes for the American People. Fines if you do not have coverage, negotiated rates by the woman who oversaw one of the most onerous health programs in the nation, mandatory coverage? This is not public health care options - this is coercive lobbyist policy making and in America, I for one have had enough! It is time for this Congress to be given it walking papers! I will be working through 2010 to stop this kind of legislature from continuing in office. It is not only hypocritical, it is so corrupt that it has sold out its integrity and its honor, as well as that of the American People, to pander to a group of individuals and corporations who are so intent on creating a sick and weak nation to maintain their control of its government, that only a few members of the body should be kept from facing criminal charges. It is time for our nation to join other industrial nations in caring for our people. Contrary to Blue Dogs, Republicans, and idiots, a universal health care program or a strong public option without fines is both common sense and good government. It does not need to be paid for by cuts in Medicare (except to rid ourselves of the so-called non-profit insurance company administrators - which is a lie), and a tax on higher incomes will not result in a loss of productivity and the only reason insurance company premiums will go up is to make up for the losses they will experience when all the people they have harmed accept a public option that will cost them about $27.78 a month per person if 300,000,000 of us were to avail ourselves of a program that should be as fine as the one Congress gives itself and we pay for. And that rate would not change for 10 years! It is time for honesty in government and truth in information dispersal, but mostly it is time for Americans to take back their governance. Mr. President, if you sign this bill which is nothing short of atrocious legislation by a corrupt Congress, you will have sealed your fate with the American People. You will be shown to be a liar and a betrayer of the promises you made to us when we elected you. VETO the bill that is coming unless it does what you promised us - universal health care. or a strong public option; no fines; and no caps on negotiated prices or services. VETO it if so much as one item available to the members of Congress is not included in this plan. VETO it until we can get you a new Congress next year, and let the American people know that you did it because you believe in keeping your promises and this bill will not do anything other than benefit insurance companies and harm the American Public - and then name names on who voted against it and do not support one Blue Dog Democrat or other Democrat next year who did not support a decent health care reform bill (which I guess means most of Congress, including Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi, who have just sold us out with their ideas on what the bill should have). You made a promise to America, Mr. President - NOW KEEP IT!

BASE TO DEMOCRATS..., BASE

BASE TO DEMOCRATS..., BASE TO DEMOCRATS..., COME IN DEMOCRATS..., OVER...zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz...BASE TO DEMOCRATS..., BSAE TO DEMOCRATS..., COME IN DEMOCRATS..., OVER...zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz...

What ever happened to term

What ever happened to term limits? It's time to resume the discussion.

Why doesn't the POTUS sign

Why doesn't the POTUS sign an Executive Order outlawing he Republican Party; dismissing all Republicans for the House and from the Senate. Whallla you've done away with US!

Hightower has the corporate

Hightower has the corporate bottom feeders in congress miss-named. They're not closet socialists. That is not what socialism is about, they are Fascists clear and simple. READ Mussolini's definition. ~John l.