Stolen Land, Stolen Trees, Stolen Livelihoods
Saturday 31 July 2010
by: Laura Finley, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

(Photo: Chris Yunker / Flickr)
Imagine your livelihood is farming. You grow a variety of products that have sustained you and your family for generations. Then, imagine that the Army decides to erect a long fence that blocks you from accessing your farm. They say you will be able to get a permit to enter your own land, but when you apply, you are denied. The only person they will give the permit to is your elderly father, who cannot possible tend the land as needed and support the family. Already poor, your future is grim.
In 2003, the Israeli Army built just such a fence/wall in the occupied West Bank village of Jayyus. Today, more than 100 farmers are unable to access their farmland and, thus, have essentially lost their livelihood, as many rely solely on their olive, citrus and other trees for income. More than 50 percent of West Bank residents live below the poverty line, with some 26 percent living in extreme poverty. While the fence/wall was being built, the Israeli Army promised the villagers free access to their land. They are not following through on this promise, as only 18-20 percent of Jayyus farmers have been granted permits to access their land. Obtaining a permit is time consuming and expensive and, thus, prohibitive for many.
On July 9, 2004, the Israeli Court of Justice issued an advisory opinion, declaring that the fence/wall does not lie solely on the Green Line, but, instead, some 80 percent of it is on Palestinian land inside the West Bank. This violates the conditions of the 1949 Armistice Line that separates the State of Israel from the occupied West Bank. The court ruled that the placement of the fence is unlawful, as it appropriates large sections of land owned by Palestinian farmers.
Amnesty International USA (AIUSA) has called this a human rights violation and is working to help these farmers obtain permits to access their land. AIUSA is also asking that the Israeli government issue permits to all Jayyus residents who have been denied them in the past, with the eventual result of full access to the farmland for all Jayyus farmers.
According to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, all people have the human right to freedom of movement and residence. They have the right to own property and cannot be arbitrarily deprived of that right. Please consider contacting the Israeli prime minister and minister of foreign affairs or your local political leaders to seek justice for the farmers of Jayyus.

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
I am far from supporting the
Sat, 07/31/2010 - 17:46 β Robert Sadin (not verified)I am far from supporting the policies of the Israeli government.
But this is about 100 farmers.
In the Congo, the death toll is in the millions!!!
But this doesn't seem to be too important.
Human slavery continues in the Sudan...
Homosexuality illegal in large portions of the world including the Middle East (Israel being the principal exception)
Child brides as young as 7 in India and much of world.
Sexual trafficking at epidemic proportions.
This and so much more gets the rare, article.
But the plight of the Palestinians...
A daily dose doesn't seem to be enough.
When a policeman arrests a Black man for jaywalking, but ignores the assault and battery of a white man, we rightly complain of selective enforcement of the laws.
This should apply on a global scale as well.
This Wall is a monstrosity.
Sat, 07/31/2010 - 17:49 β Anonymous (not verified)This Wall is a monstrosity. There is no excuse for it. All the reasons given are complete bullshit. It is simply another way to steal land, also by making the Palestinians unable to feed themselves or earn any kind of living. The Israelis must know full well that if you build a Wall to stop suicide bombers, then the anger will be diverted elsewhere. But nothing deters them. Besides this, the Wall means that the Israelis are inside it with all their weapons pointing over it. They are cutting themselves off from the rest of the world. What a very sad State it is.
For anyone interested, there are two excellent films: Budrus, directed by Julia Bacha, shows the peaceful resistance of a village to the Wall cutting them off from their land. The film Wall by Simone Bitton concerns the buidling of the Wall, the position Israel takes and the consequences for Palestinians.
Mr. Sadin all the things you
Sat, 07/31/2010 - 18:33 β Citizen of the World (not verified)Mr. Sadin all the things you mentioned in your post are wrong, and so is Israel stealing Palestinians land and depriving them of their livelihood. Lets call something what it is.
I did see the film Budrus and I only wish it was in national distribution so people could actually see what is really happening.
The wall is not a
Sat, 07/31/2010 - 18:50 β Stan Nadel (not verified)The wall is not a monstrosity, its location is. The author of this message seems to have forgotten the large number of terrorist bombings directed against the civilian population that preceded the building of the wall. Many countries have built walls on their borders with less reason and hardly anyone complains about them. If the Israeli wall followed the green line border their would be no cause for complaint, so let's focus on the real issue. Or does anonymous really want to see the return of the terrorist bombers?
They are the CHOSEN PEOPLE
Sat, 07/31/2010 - 18:59 β Anonymous (not verified)They are the CHOSEN PEOPLE therefore the law does not apply to them.
As more of my fellow
Sat, 07/31/2010 - 20:15 β Anonymous (not verified)As more of my fellow Americans are made to understand the brutal tactics employed by the Israelis in their war of extermination against the Palestinians, I would hope that the continuing support for these dreadful people will cease. I do not want any more of my tax monies being funneled to the present war criminals currently administering the country. I also hope that we are looking to find the Israeli spies who, like the Russians recently apprehended, need to be sent out of the country - the ones who steal our nuclear secrets and anything else of use in their quest to destroy the people whose land they stole and are continuing to steal.
DUPLICITY, TREASON and
Sat, 07/31/2010 - 23:49 β Arminius Aurelius (not verified)DUPLICITY, TREASON and MURDER
Never Forget
WWW.USSLIBERTY.ORG
I challenge the editors and
Sun, 08/01/2010 - 03:14 β Robert Sadin (not verified)I challenge the editors and the readers of Truthout to compare the number of column inches devoted to Israel and compare it to the column inches devoted to atrocities in which MILLIONS die.
Human slavery, rape which cannot be prosecuted without 4 male witnesses, homosexuals jailed or executed, protesters shot on a regular basis, turning of poor countries and poor neighborhoods into carcinogenic toxic waste dumps.
None of this is worth more than the occasional mention.
Yes, many Palestinians live in poverty, unjustly so. When is the last time this much attention has been devoted to the condition of Native Americans here. People with a right to the land beyond all dispute!!!
When Ronald Reagan carried on about one African American who defrauded the welfare system while turning a blind eye to corporate crimes of monumental proportion, the left was outraged.
But when Israel is excoriated for every misdeed while a fraction of that attention is given to crimes where mutilation, murder, slavery, go on on a massive scale, the left is guilty of a similar distorted and diversionary perspective.
Mr. Sadin Israel involves
Sun, 08/01/2010 - 06:59 β gehan (not verified)Mr. Sadin
Israel involves itself intimately in American politics - it is only natural we should write about them a lot.
Mr. Sarin sounds like a
Sun, 08/01/2010 - 14:35 β Anonymous (not verified)Mr. Sarin sounds like a child, caught in the act, saying his brother is worse. Wrong is wrong.
Mr. Sadin, the difference
Sun, 08/01/2010 - 19:08 β Anonymous (not verified)Mr. Sadin,
the difference between this and the other atrocities you mention is that the wall is being built with US tax money; therefore it's reasonable to assume that we share in the responsibility for it and are entitled to make a fuss about it. While the injustices you mention in India, etc. affect more people, US complicity is less direct.
Also, while THIS case may affect only 100 farmers, it is certainly part of a pattern that affects hundreds of thousands of Palestinians.
Stan Nadel, If you are going
Sun, 08/01/2010 - 21:07 β Roslyn Ross (not verified)Stan Nadel, If you are going to try to excuse the wall then start at the wall and work back:
The wall was built supposedly to stop attacks from Palestinians (but it's route clearly shows it is a landgrab). The Palestinians attack because they are occupied by Israel and their land continues to be colonised. Every human being has a right to live in freedom. Every indigenous people, and the Palestinians are the indigenous people of Palestine and what is now called Israel, have a right to either their own country in what is left of their land or in one State with equal rights for all; i.e. as other colonising nations like the US have done. There would be no wall if there were no attacks; there would be no attacks if Palestine had not been occupied and colonised. Ergo, the problem is not with the wall, nor the attacks by Palestinians but by Israel's occupation and continued colonisation. The Israeli occupation of Palestine is one of the most brutal and murderous in the modern age. If you were a Palestinian you would also attack your oppressor. If you were a coloniser and occupier with conscience you would end the occupation, negotiate final borders, pay compensation for suffering caused to the indigenous people and then there would be no attacks... and no wall.
I am glad to read the
Sun, 08/01/2010 - 22:00 β Anonymous (not verified)I am glad to read the comments defending justice in Palestine, they are prevailing. Yes, it is our moral duty to finish with the oppression in Palestine. Especially when it is paid by the US taxpayer and other european prerogatives. Walls and phosphor bombs are crimes against humanity. Israel is certainly the most criminel "democratic state" on earth. Israel will be isolated because of its neverending crimes against humanity.
Let's set one fact straight
Tue, 08/03/2010 - 03:35 β Anonymous (not verified)Let's set one fact straight to clear up whom is to blame, terrorists or Israeli thieves: FACT is that the Israelis began stealing and occupying Palestinian lands first, then Palestinians reacted by blowing up innocent people in Israel. The United States continues monetary and bizarro support for "our friends" the Israelis, which endangers Americans everywhere because of a double standard State policy by the U.S. Peace can be won by compromise, understanding, and willingness.